DELAWARE SUPREME COURT UPHOLDS JUDGE'S FINDING THAT TESLA ACQUISITION OF SOLAR CITY WAS FAIR

Delaware's Supreme Court has upheld a judge's decision in favor of Tesla CEO Elon Musk in a lawsuit challenging the electric car maker's $2.4 billion acquisition of a solar panel company founded by two of his cousins.

- 

The court on Tuesday rejected arguments from a group of Tesla shareholders that a Chancery Court judge erred in finding that Tesla's deal to acquire SolarCity in 2016 was "entirely fair!" The judge made that determination even while finding that the process by which Tesla's board of directors negotiated and recommended the deal to shareholders was "far from perfect." 

While noting errors in the trial court's fair price analysis, and agreeing that the deal process was not "pitch perfect," the justices said the record is replete with factual findings and credibility determinations indicating that the acquisition was "entirely fair."

"We are convinced, after a thorough review of the extensive trial record, that the trial court's decision is supported by the evidence and that the court committed no reversible error in applying the entire fairness test," Justice Karen Valihura wrote in the court's 106-page opinion.