Try GOLD - Free
TRADE TENSIONS
Down To Earth
|March 01, 2025
Why the benefits of agroforestry carbon trade do not trickle down to farmers
-
IN THEORY, agroforestry carbon credit projects can be a win-win solution for both the communities and environment. Though such projects are picking up in India, DTE's interaction with farmers and analysis of project documents show that farmers rarely benefit from the carbon revenue—and this has to do with the design of the voluntary carbon market as well as the lack of transparency in the agreements with poor communities.
PRICING WOES
First, in a voluntary carbon market, as the name suggests, prices are determined by an agreement between a buyer (a company looking to retire a credit) and a seller (a project developer, for instance). "The price is a question of what buyers are willing to pay and at what price project developers are willing to sell. There is no regulation of the price," Lambert Schneider, research coordinator for International Climate Policy at Oeko-Institut in Berlin, tells DTE. However, buyers are willing to pay a premium for high-quality carbon credits, such as credits generated from projects that pass the additionality check (removals from the project would not have occurred without the revenue from the sale of carbon credits), and offers co-benefits for biodiversity and local communities.
This story is from the March 01, 2025 edition of Down To Earth.
Subscribe to Magzter GOLD to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 10,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
MORE STORIES FROM Down To Earth
Down To Earth
The life of water
A THREE-PART FILM SERIES THAT LOOKS AT ACCESS AND AVAILABILITY OF WATER IN INDIA THROUGH A SOCIO-ECONOMIC PRISM, HIGHLIGHTING THE NATURAL RESOURCE'S INTEGRAL LINK TO AGRICULTURE, HEALTH AND POLITICS
4 mins
November 01, 2025
Down To Earth
Rays of change
From dark nights to uninterrupted electricity, rooftop solar has brought independence, health and prosperity to a Maharashtra village
3 mins
November 01, 2025
Down To Earth
Back to the roots
Over 200 tribal villages in Madhya Pradesh are turning to forests to restore food security, breaking free from years of market dependence
5 mins
November 01, 2025
Down To Earth
How to slash a drug price by 97 per cent
Rulings that bar patent extensions on flimsy grounds by drug giants are opening the gates to dramatically cheaper generic medicines
4 mins
November 01, 2025
Down To Earth
TAINTED FLOW
Panipat shows an overreliance on groundwater even as residents remain wary of its contamination due to untreated discharge of textile recycling wastewater
3 mins
November 01, 2025
Down To Earth
Flushed and forgotten
Poor containment systems, weak monitoring and illegal dumping have turned Uttar Pradesh's faecal sludge handling into an environmental ticking bomb
4 mins
November 01, 2025
Down To Earth
Let soil live
IT IS just a start, but the message is loud and clear. At the International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN) World Conservation Congress in Abu Dhabi this October, “Motion 007: Soil Security Law” was presented for formal voting, aiming to give soil security the urgent legal recognition it requires.
2 mins
November 01, 2025
Down To Earth
To do or not to do
AS I write this, there is massive churning in the world—not the kind that makes headlines, but deeper undercurrents: collisions of powerful forces working against each other. What will emerge as the victor? At this point, the only certainty is uncertainty.
3 mins
November 01, 2025
Down To Earth
FADING REEFS
Warm-water corals are the first major ecosystem to collapse in a rapidly warming planet. Scientists are racing to save them using cutting-edge technologies, from preserving spawn to breeding hardier varieties, but admit their efforts may fall short unless global temperature rises are limited to below 1.5°C.
5 mins
November 01, 2025
Down To Earth
Emphasis on rebuilding Gaza post-truce
ON OCTOBER 10, Israel and Palestine declared a ceasefire after a two-year war that led to the deaths of thousands of people and led to mass displacement and a famine in the disputed Gaza strip.
1 min
November 01, 2025
Listen
Translate
Change font size
