Try GOLD - Free

Man United ignoring reality of their failings is madness

The Independent

|

October 03, 2025

Ruben Amorim's commitment to 3-4-3 is a bizarre refusal to face the facts about his players' abilities

- Richard Jolly

Man United ignoring reality of their failings is madness

At left wing-back, the player who won the Champions League as a No 10. At right wing-back, the forward who scored 20 Premier League goals last season. Manchester United finished Saturday's defeat at Brentford with what could seem the latest example of Ruben Amorim's determination to put the squarest of pegs in the roundest of holes but with yet another illustration that the system is paramount. Amorim may die upon a hill, if that hill is labelled 3-4-3. Wing-backs are here as long as he is, even if they aren’t really wing-backs.

Which, to compound the sense that Amorim’s dogma is holding United back, few are. Certainly not Mason Mount or Bryan Mbeumo, the duo who ended the Brentford game out of position. But also not Diogo Dalot or Noussair Mazraoui, who are more often found there. Each has the willingness to give it a go, but is essentially a fullback. Perhaps Patrick Dorgu is, too, though it is harder to tell. Amad Diallo is a winger at heart; like Dalot and Mazraoui, his best role is rendered redundant by Amorim. He has to compromise to play.

And while Amorim has spent some £200m on new forwards, Mbeumo included, this summer, the wing-backs explain why his United are a low-scoring team. The Portuguese could point out that two of United’s three Premier League assists this season came from his wide men: Dalot for Mbeumo against Burnley, Dorgu for Casemiro against Chelsea.

image

MORE STORIES FROM The Independent

The Independent

The Independent

What's my best option to break this marathon flight?

Q I have a work trip to Buenos Aires in February.

time to read

1 mins

December 14, 2025

The Independent

The Independent

The art of leaving the party

December is the most wonderful time of the year, but it's also exhausting.

time to read

4 mins

December 14, 2025

The Independent

The Independent

Fans need the FA to speak up and take on Fifa's rip-off

With ticket prices for next summer's World Cup five times higher than in 2022, governing bodies must show that the game doesn't accept this 'betrayal'

time to read

5 mins

December 14, 2025

The Independent

The Independent

Riga rightly in the running for 2026's coolest city break

The capital of Latvia is undergoing a cultural renaissance, Here's how to soak in its vibrant art scene, inspiring architecture and chic cafe culture

time to read

5 mins

December 14, 2025

The Independent

The Independent

A READER'S PARADISE

York is not just a city for lovers of history - it's the UK's indie bookshop capital. Local Rory Buccheri is your guide to the best hangouts for those who enjoy getting lost in a good tome

time to read

5 mins

December 14, 2025

The Independent

The Independent

Why Trump's peacekeeping bids are doomed to failure

The US president claims to have resolved several disputes but experts tell Alex Croft his deals are inherently unstable

time to read

4 mins

December 14, 2025

The Independent

The Independent

Robinson leads rally to 'put Christ back into Christmas'

Far-right activist Tommy Robinson has led a carol concert to “put the Christ back into Christmas”.

time to read

1 mins

December 14, 2025

The Independent

The Independent

Venue apology over use of alleged antisemitic imagery

Rock band Primal Scream have been accused of displaying “grossly antisemitic” imagery at a London concert.

time to read

2 mins

December 14, 2025

The Independent

The Independent

Doctors accuse Streeting of ‘scaremongering’ on strikes

BMA denies that action could push NHS towards collapse

time to read

3 mins

December 14, 2025

The Independent

The Independent

No Channel crossings for 28 days is seven-year record

The UK has recorded the longest period without migrants arriving on small boats crossing the Channel for seven years, official figures show. Before this weekend, no one had completed the perilous crossing for 28 days, since 14 November, according to the latest Home Office data.

time to read

1 mins

December 14, 2025

Listen

Translate

Share

-
+

Change font size