Poging GOUD - Vrij

Man United ignoring reality of their failings is madness

The Independent

|

October 03, 2025

Ruben Amorim's commitment to 3-4-3 is a bizarre refusal to face the facts about his players' abilities

- Richard Jolly

Man United ignoring reality of their failings is madness

At left wing-back, the player who won the Champions League as a No 10. At right wing-back, the forward who scored 20 Premier League goals last season. Manchester United finished Saturday's defeat at Brentford with what could seem the latest example of Ruben Amorim's determination to put the squarest of pegs in the roundest of holes but with yet another illustration that the system is paramount. Amorim may die upon a hill, if that hill is labelled 3-4-3. Wing-backs are here as long as he is, even if they aren’t really wing-backs.

Which, to compound the sense that Amorim’s dogma is holding United back, few are. Certainly not Mason Mount or Bryan Mbeumo, the duo who ended the Brentford game out of position. But also not Diogo Dalot or Noussair Mazraoui, who are more often found there. Each has the willingness to give it a go, but is essentially a fullback. Perhaps Patrick Dorgu is, too, though it is harder to tell. Amad Diallo is a winger at heart; like Dalot and Mazraoui, his best role is rendered redundant by Amorim. He has to compromise to play.

And while Amorim has spent some £200m on new forwards, Mbeumo included, this summer, the wing-backs explain why his United are a low-scoring team. The Portuguese could point out that two of United’s three Premier League assists this season came from his wide men: Dalot for Mbeumo against Burnley, Dorgu for Casemiro against Chelsea.

image

MEER VERHALEN VAN The Independent

The Independent

The Independent

Hamilton seeks reset after his 'worst' F1 season ever

Lewis Hamilton, at the conclusion of his 19th and worst season in Formula One, could not have been more unambiguous. “No one’s going to be able to get hold of me this winter,” he said, after the season finale in Abu Dhabi on Sunday.

time to read

4 mins

December 15, 2025

The Independent

The Independent

‘To me, the song is like a fine wine, it grows on you’

As a recording of the first live performance of 'Fairytale of New York' is released, producer Steve Lillywhite reflects on what makes the song so special.

time to read

3 mins

December 15, 2025

The Independent

The Independent

Can we trust banks to tell us how to get rich by investing?

Sharp sales practices by dodgy blokes in shiny suits have been responsible for a long and sorry list of scandals costing billions.

time to read

3 mins

December 15, 2025

The Independent

The Independent

Own goal decides derby as North East rivalry renewed

In victory, there was one last act of revenge for Sunderland players to perform against the North East rivals they love to torment in the Premier League.

time to read

4 mins

December 15, 2025

The Independent

The Independent

Top 10 TV shows of 2025

Nick Hilton and Patrick Smith count down the greatest television this year had to offer, from agenda-setting dramas to poignant documentaries and irresistible reality TV

time to read

5 mins

December 15, 2025

The Independent

The Independent

PAY ATTENTION

From shrinking attention spans to the rise of 'brain rot' content, Helen Coffey looks at why concentration is sagging and what experts say might restore our ability to think deeply

time to read

9 mins

December 15, 2025

The Independent

The Independent

A round of applause for a mocked festive tradition

The round robin was once a festive failsafe, but has sadly died out. Now that oversharing and humble bragging are rife on social media, Katie Rosseinsky asks if it's time to revive them

time to read

4 mins

December 15, 2025

The Independent

The Independent

Why is Gen Z so obsessed with 'almost relationships'?

Nothing is as romantic as a relationship that never quite happened. Preserved in possibility, it’s a near-miss dynamic that exists in an exclusively liminal space; you’re not quite together, but there’s enough evidence to suggest that one day, were all the stars to suddenly align, you might be. And so you cling on, wondering, waiting, hoping.

time to read

2 mins

December 15, 2025

The Independent

The Independent

'We must do what we can to support those affected – so many must be frightened'

Philanthropist boosts The Independent's SafeCall campaign

time to read

2 mins

December 15, 2025

The Independent

The Independent

Egypt hoping for a tourism boost from restored statues

Egypt has officially unveiled meticulously restored colossal statues of an ancient pharaoh in the southern city of Luxor – an event designed to bolster the nation’s vital tourism sector.

time to read

2 mins

December 15, 2025

Listen

Translate

Share

-
+

Change font size