Try GOLD - Free

Philanthropic Saint?

Outlook

|

November 01, 2024

Why it is necessary to speak about the Adivasis when we talk about Ratan Tata

- Gladson Dungdung

Philanthropic Saint?

THE death of a human being, be it a common man or a celebrity, is always sad. Ratan Tata, the well-known industrialist, is no different in this episode. Without doubt, his demise is a sad event and a huge loss for the country. But is there any justification for his anointment by the capital-intoxicated intellectuals, politicians, business class, media and middle class as a "philanthropic saint"? The newspapers carry eulogistic columns, special reports fill the TV channels, and social media is flooded with encomia. The general view seems to be that there was no other industrialist in the country who was so humble, kind, charitable, caring and people-loving as Ratan Tata. None had his concern for the growth of the country's economy, the well-being of the employees and the improvement of the lives of the poor.

The most surprising aspect of these tributes that have been pouring in from all quarters is that they have no mention of the Adivasis. Can any account of Tata be complete without them? What, then, explains this glaring exclusion? Are there apprehensions that talking about the Adivasis would expose Tata’s real face? But without the Adivasis, could the Tatas have built such a vast business empire in the first place? Posed differently, the question is: why is it necessary to talk about the Adivasis while talking about Ratan Tata?

MORE STORIES FROM Outlook

Outlook

Outlook

Chop and Change

India should not align itself with the American camp. It should continue to assert its strategic autonomy

time to read

7 mins

September 21, 2025

Outlook

Outlook

Has the Maharaja Stopped Dancing?

To his credit, Rajinikanth made the transition from cinema that was made for single screens and their unruly audiences to new-age films in which we see his young, VFX version

time to read

7 mins

September 21, 2025

Outlook

Outlook

Two to Tango

Keeping relations on an even keel with China is important for India's economic growth, but joining a world order led by it would be suicidal

time to read

5 mins

September 21, 2025

Outlook

Multipolarity or a New Bipolarity?

Even as Beijing continues to challenge conventional notions of democracy and human rights, America will have to decide what it stands for and what it wants from the world

time to read

7 mins

September 21, 2025

Outlook

Outlook

You Have no Enemies, you say?

India’s interests lie in a closer strategic partnership with the US, just as any American administration cannot ignore the world’s most populous country that is in a critical geography and has economic and military potential

time to read

4 mins

September 21, 2025

Outlook

Outlook

How Fragile we are

Tariff turbulence and India's pursuit of strategic autonomy

time to read

9 mins

September 21, 2025

Outlook

Chasing a Chimera

India, China and Russia as well as most of the developing countries are committed to a multipolar world where policies are not decided by just one or two countries, but there are several power poles

time to read

7 mins

September 21, 2025

Outlook

Outlook

Behind the Mask

There is a pressing need to map the gaps between branding claims and effective achievements on the foreign policy front, based on the parameters set by the Modi government itself

time to read

7 mins

September 21, 2025

Outlook

Outlook

The Tianjin Trifecta

Is India the face of the forces directed by Russia in a new, turbocharged geopolitical vehicle designed and built by China?

time to read

7 mins

September 21, 2025

Outlook

Outlook

Lyrically Yours

A remarkable travelogue across Indian cities through the years

time to read

5 mins

September 11, 2025

Listen

Translate

Share

-
+

Change font size