يحاول ذهب - حر
Philanthropic Saint?
November 01, 2024
|Outlook
Why it is necessary to speak about the Adivasis when we talk about Ratan Tata

THE death of a human being, be it a common man or a celebrity, is always sad. Ratan Tata, the well-known industrialist, is no different in this episode. Without doubt, his demise is a sad event and a huge loss for the country. But is there any justification for his anointment by the capital-intoxicated intellectuals, politicians, business class, media and middle class as a "philanthropic saint"? The newspapers carry eulogistic columns, special reports fill the TV channels, and social media is flooded with encomia. The general view seems to be that there was no other industrialist in the country who was so humble, kind, charitable, caring and people-loving as Ratan Tata. None had his concern for the growth of the country's economy, the well-being of the employees and the improvement of the lives of the poor.
The most surprising aspect of these tributes that have been pouring in from all quarters is that they have no mention of the Adivasis. Can any account of Tata be complete without them? What, then, explains this glaring exclusion? Are there apprehensions that talking about the Adivasis would expose Tata’s real face? But without the Adivasis, could the Tatas have built such a vast business empire in the first place? Posed differently, the question is: why is it necessary to talk about the Adivasis while talking about Ratan Tata?
هذه القصة من طبعة November 01, 2024 من Outlook.
اشترك في Magzter GOLD للوصول إلى آلاف القصص المتميزة المنسقة، وأكثر من 9000 مجلة وصحيفة.
هل أنت مشترك بالفعل؟ تسجيل الدخول
المزيد من القصص من Outlook

Outlook
Throwback to the 80s
In Nepal, the struggle for democracy is not an event; it is a craft practiced across generations, passed like a lamp from hand to hand
12 mins
October 01, 2025

Outlook
Home and the World
This genre-defying novel elegantly melds memoir, travelogue and fiction
3 mins
October 01, 2025

Outlook
The Revolution is Giving
Discord, a chat app built for gamers, was transformed into an unlikely parliament in Nepal
13 mins
October 01, 2025
Outlook
Waqf Pe Kiya, Kya Haseen Sitam
The petitions challenging the Waqf (Amendment) Act, 2025, could remain in cold storage while the evil inherent in the statute plays itself out
10 mins
October 01, 2025

Outlook
Rain and Ruin
In the last 50 years, Punjab has witnessed several devastating floods that have left deep scars on its landscape and people
4 mins
October 01, 2025

Outlook
Ok Boomer, Time's Up
People and politicians came together to establish democracy, and then they parted ways. Now they are faced with the challenge of putting the democracy back together
7 mins
October 01, 2025

Outlook
Curse of the Cusecs
As people join hands to pick up the pieces of lives disrupted by Punjab's worst flood since 1988, the spotlight turns on the management of water resources as an arena for inter-state and state-Centre sparring
7 mins
October 01, 2025

Outlook
What's the Vibe Now?
The changes in Nepal offer a sublime chance to New Delhi to recalibrate its policy provided it proceeds with caution and humility
5 mins
October 01, 2025
Outlook
Of Stories and Storyteller
The plan was to have tamatar chaat at the famous Kashi Chaat Bhandar, situated en route Dashashwamedh ghaat. There was a catch, though. From the chowk where we were standing, all we could see was a sea of people. It was time for the Ganga aarti, on the left were people queued up to enter the Kashi Vishwanath temple through the brand-new corridor, on the right were people taking Ganesh idols for immersion and joining the festivities were those who were winding up Eid celebrations.
3 mins
October 01, 2025

Outlook
UDID Certification Rise, Yet Disability Inclusion Faces Challenges
Intellectual disability (ID) remains one of the most overlooked areas of public health in India, where many individuals with disabilities are still confined to their homes due to social stigma, lack of resources, and limited opportunities for education and employment.
4 mins
October 01, 2025
Listen
Translate
Change font size