Denemek ALTIN - Özgür
Politicians may be breathing a sigh of relief as clear ruling lets them dodge difficult questions
The Guardian
|April 17, 2025
For all the negative stereotypes, many politicians are thoughtful, diligent and caring. But they are also human, and it is their more self-serving instincts that may have caused some to breathe a sigh of relief at the supreme court ruling on gender recognition.
After a challenge by the gender-critical group For Women Scotland - which started out as a dispute over Scottish government legislation about female representation on public boards - judges ruled that the terms "woman" and "sex" in the Equality Act refer to biological women and biological sex.
The verdict will be heavily contested, and could bring serious and perhaps unforeseen repercussions for transgender women. But such an unexpectedly definitive view allows leaders in both Scotland and Westminster to (and there is no gentle way of putting this) dodge responsibility over one of the most contentious and toxic debates of our age.
The Scottish government's response was particularly eloquent. While stressing that no one should see the ruling as cause for triumph, it otherwise talked blandly about "engaging with the UK government to understand the full implication of this ruling".
There is logic to this. The Equality Act and the Gender Recognition Act, the legislative focus of the deliberations, are both UK-wide and thus not something the Holyrood administration can decide unilaterally.
Bu hikaye The Guardian dergisinin April 17, 2025 baskısından alınmıştır.
Binlerce özenle seçilmiş premium hikayeye ve 9.000'den fazla dergi ve gazeteye erişmek için Magzter GOLD'a abone olun.
Zaten abone misiniz? Oturum aç
The Guardian'den DAHA FAZLA HİKAYE
The Guardian
'Heroic' rail worker in fight for life after tackling train knife attacker
Single suspect held over stabbings as 11 victims are treated in hospital
3 mins
November 03, 2025
The Guardian
World Cup wave leaves Saracens riding high in the sun
The stars came out to dazzle a record Saracens crowd in a 47-10 derby win for the home side against Harlequins
3 mins
November 03, 2025
The Guardian
Goal machine Haaland's latest double fires City up to second
But Guardiola still criticises refereeing standards at Etihad by saying: They're brave here’
1 mins
November 03, 2025
The Guardian
Southampton sack Still as club slide into the danger zone
Southampton have sacked Will Still after the club dropped closer to the Championship relegation zone.
1 min
November 03, 2025
The Guardian
UK workforce risks loss of extra 600,000 people to poor health - study
An extra 600,000 people will leave the workforce in the next decade because of long-term health conditions unless there is \"a fundamental shift\" in how employers help maintain staff well-being, a report says.
1 mins
November 03, 2025
The Guardian
Nuno hails fans as Hammers hit back in rare win
Nuno Espírito Santo said that his West Ham team had given their fans “something small” to cling on to with a first victory of his tenure and that he hoped a performance of grit, ability and, perhaps most importantly, belief would give them momentum in their fight against relegation.
3 mins
November 03, 2025
The Guardian
Cycles of power The young bike fans reclaiming the streets of Johannesburg
On a hot Saturday spring morning, Karabo Mashele urged a group of female cyclists up the hills of a plush Johannesburg suburb.
3 mins
November 03, 2025
The Guardian
Shafali and Deepti the home heroes as India make history
Wolvaardt hits another hundred but South Africa pay for dropped catches in final
3 mins
November 03, 2025
The Guardian
Reeves is warned not to cut VAT on electricity bills
Proposals being considered by Rachel Reeves to cut tax on electricity bills will backfire, experts have warned, resulting in a giveaway to richer homeowners and undermining the UK's climate commitments.
3 mins
November 03, 2025
The Guardian
Wolves eye O'Neil and Edwards after Pereira exits
Wolves could turn to their former head coach Gary O'Neil after sacking Vítor Pereira, with Middlesbrough's Rob Edwards another leading candidate.
2 mins
November 03, 2025
Listen
Translate
Change font size
