يحاول ذهب - حر

Politicians may be breathing a sigh of relief as clear ruling lets them dodge difficult questions

April 17, 2025

|

The Guardian

For all the negative stereotypes, many politicians are thoughtful, diligent and caring. But they are also human, and it is their more self-serving instincts that may have caused some to breathe a sigh of relief at the supreme court ruling on gender recognition.

- Peter Walker and Severin Carrell

After a challenge by the gender-critical group For Women Scotland - which started out as a dispute over Scottish government legislation about female representation on public boards - judges ruled that the terms "woman" and "sex" in the Equality Act refer to biological women and biological sex.

The verdict will be heavily contested, and could bring serious and perhaps unforeseen repercussions for transgender women. But such an unexpectedly definitive view allows leaders in both Scotland and Westminster to (and there is no gentle way of putting this) dodge responsibility over one of the most contentious and toxic debates of our age.

The Scottish government's response was particularly eloquent. While stressing that no one should see the ruling as cause for triumph, it otherwise talked blandly about "engaging with the UK government to understand the full implication of this ruling".

There is logic to this. The Equality Act and the Gender Recognition Act, the legislative focus of the deliberations, are both UK-wide and thus not something the Holyrood administration can decide unilaterally.

المزيد من القصص من The Guardian

The Guardian

The Guardian

India's World Cup heroics deserve a long-lasting legacy

Stunning home triumph has upended the status quo and should serve as a wake-up call to nation's powerbrokers

time to read

3 mins

November 04, 2025

The Guardian

Apec summit Xi shows his lighter side with phone gag

It would take someone with nerves of steel to joke about the security of Chinese smartphones in front of Xi Jinping. Step forward the South Korean president, Lee Jae Myung, who, after being given two of the devices by his Chinese counterpart at a state banquet, wondered out loud whether they were secure.

time to read

1 mins

November 04, 2025

The Guardian

Pregnant British teenager held in Georgian prison is released

The British teenager Bella May Culley has been released from a Georgian prison, after payment of a substantial fine as part of a plea agreement.

time to read

1 min

November 04, 2025

The Guardian

The Guardian

Steward injury could offer Smith chance to make fresh start with England

Full-back spot may be up for grabs with Daly and Furbank already ruled out

time to read

2 mins

November 04, 2025

The Guardian

OpenAI in £29bn datacentre deal with Amazon

OpenAI has signed a $38bn (£29bn) deal to use Amazon Web Services to operate its artificial intelligence products as part of a more than $1tn spending spree on computing power.

time to read

1 min

November 04, 2025

The Guardian

O'Neil stuns Wolves after walking away from return

Gary O'Neil has stunned Wolves by withdrawing from talks to return to the club as head coach.

time to read

1 min

November 04, 2025

The Guardian

From stocking filler to floor filler: John Lewis Christmas advert channels nightclub nostalgia

John Lewis is hoping that a dash of nostalgia will get consumers into the festive mood this year as it officially kickstarts the countdown to Christmas with the launch of its 2025 advert - to the tune of the 1990s club classic Where Love Lives.

time to read

3 mins

November 04, 2025

The Guardian

TalkTV broke impartiality rules with local elections claim, says Ofcom

TalkTV, the online channel owned by Rupert Murdoch's News UK, breached impartiality rules in a show that repeatedly accused the government of cancelling local elections out of fear of Reform UK, the media regulator said yesterday.

time to read

1 min

November 04, 2025

The Guardian

PM 'told of Mandelson's relationship with Epstein before ambassador appointment'

Keir Starmer was briefed on details of Peter Mandelson's relationship with Jeffrey Epstein before he decided to appoint him US ambassador, senior civil servants said yesterday.

time to read

2 mins

November 04, 2025

The Guardian

The victims Footballer among 11 hospitalised

One of the passengers stabbed in the train attack in Cambridgeshire was named yesterday as a footballer with Scunthorpe United.

time to read

2 mins

November 04, 2025

Listen

Translate

Share

-
+

Change font size