Giftedness: The Nature And The Nurture Debate
Parent Circle|September 2016

What do we mean when we use the term ‘gifted’ to refer to a child? Does it mean that the child inherited that spark of brilliance? Or, could the child have developed it over the years through smart parenting methods? Experts from the National Institute of Advanced Studies explain the scientific basis for us, in this exclusive write-up.

Dr Anitha Kurup & Amita Basu

The ‘Nature vs Nurture’ debate has been an eternal one. While the former stresses the influence of genetics and heredity in determining who an individual is, the latter stresses the influence of environmental factors. In order to analyse the effects of nature and nurture on giftedness, we need to understand that they are dynamic and interact with each other in ways that are complex. Every trait, not just giftedness, requires inputs from both genetics and environment. Even behavioural science has shifted away from asking whether nature or nurture determines an outcome.

Biologically, nature and nurture cannot be clearly delinked. Here’s a simple example: the environment we provide for our children depends on our attitude towards parenting and our parenting style – both of which have a strong genetic basis!

GENES VS ENVIRONMENT: THE VARIATION

Behavioural geneticists study variation in traits among individuals by separating genetic and environmental components. In a given population, genetics has a role to play in explaining the differences among people’s IQ scores. In fact, genetics strongly influences the acquisition and exercise of skills and knowledge throughout life. When we consider giftedness, it definitely has a genetic basis. But, does this imply that some families or communities are more gifted than others? Though the polymath, Sir Francis Galton, in his work, Hereditary genius (1869), claimed this was true, his findings were later contested on the ground that his research was purely correlational (links between variables) based on observing associations and making causal inferences.

Continue reading your story on the app

Continue reading your story in the magazine

MORE STORIES FROM PARENT CIRCLEView All

Dear Parent Be Interested, NOT ANXIOUS

Our anxiousness for the success of our children often translates into fear and self-doubt in children. How can we turn this anxious interest into one that is productive and supportive of the child? Find out in this exclusive feature.

6 mins read
Parent Circle
December 2016

Beauty Is Only Skin Deep

The one big puzzle for parents of teens is their adolescent’s turbulent mind. Attempting to understand it is a major challenge for them. On the other hand, teens find it difficult to explain their feelings to their parents. So, in a bid to help parents reach out to their children during this critical phase of their lives, we at ParentCircle bring you a special series, ‘The Teen Stories’. In the first part of this series, we present to you a letter from a troubled teen who worries about her appearance.

3 mins read
Parent Circle
December 2016

Aspirin Just not for kids

We’ve always thought of aspirin as a harmless but effective drug to treat fever, aches and pains. We even give it to our children. But beware! Aspirin can prove fatal if given to children below the age of 12 when they have a fever. Read on to know more.

4 mins read
Parent Circle
December 2016

Raising Kind Children

Kindness is a virtue that leads your life path towards well-being. It is a characteristic that can be expressed in multiple ways, but it’s all about being ‘happy to help’. Here’s how to teach your child to be kind.

6 mins read
Parent Circle
February 2017

How To Teach Your Child The Power Of Hard Work

In this part of our ‘Super 10 for Success’ series, find out how you can teach your child the power of hard work.

8 mins read
Parent Circle
February 2017

Be Your Own Valentine!

Note to parents: Enough with the self-judgement and guilt trips! Take these 17 vows to fall in love with yourself and rediscover the real ‘you’ this Valentine’s Day.

6 mins read
Parent Circle
February 2017

Let's Toy Around!

If you thought toys are only about fun, think again. They can also provide your child with an amazing learning experience. How? Find out as India’s favourite toy maker explains…

4 mins read
Parent Circle
February 2017

Equipping Children To Handle Disasters

Even as Cyclone Vardah took us all by ‘storm’, it brought to the fore the need to learn a very important life skill, disaster management. How does one go about it? Find out as we talk to the Director General of NDRF (National Disaster Response Force), in this exclusive conversation.   Even as Cyclone Vardah took us all by ‘storm’, it brought to the fore the need to learn a very important life skill, disaster management. How does one go about it? Find out as we talk to the Director General of NDRF (National Disaster Response Force), in this exclusive conversation.

3 mins read
Parent Circle
January 2017

India's youngest Super Chef

Be prepared for a surprise - this little one is India’s youngest chef and an international celebrity. While this prodigy’s father talks to ParentCircle about his son’s love for cooking and his amazing success at it, we have our super chef churning out some easy-to-make and exciting recipes.

5 mins read
Parent Circle
November 2016

Ask the Experts

When it comes to managing their children’s health issues, parents are quite anxious and worried. Here’s our expert addressing some parental apprehensions and concerns regarding children’s health and fitness.

2 mins read
Parent Circle
November 2016
RELATED STORIES

B&B SHOCKER: DEACON'S BACK — AND TEAMS UP WITH SHEILA!

After spending four years in prison for taking shots at Quinn, Deacon is released and heads home to see his daughter, Hope.

3 mins read
Soap Opera Digest
October 18, 2021

General hospital

GOING PLACES? Nikolas hopes news of Sonny’s return will convince Ava not to leave; she shoots him down. As part of Trina, Cameron, and Josslyn’s plan to unmask Spencer and Esme, Cam fibs to Spencer that Ava and Nikolas are taking a trip together to celebrate calling off their divorce. Joss tails Esme and sees her with Sonny. Esme catches Joss trying to eavesdrop and they trade veiled threats.

3 mins read
Soap Opera Digest
October 18, 2021

It's All Coming Back To Me Now, GENERAL HOSPITAL

Aside from portrayer Maurice Benard’s 1997-98 break from playing Sonny, daytime’s most beloved mobster has been a fixture in Port Charles since his debut in 1993 — that is, until he was presumed dead last December, and spent the lion’s share of 2021 carving out a simpler life as amnesiac “Mike” in folksy Nixon Falls.

3 mins read
Soap Opera Digest
October 18, 2021

Be Our Guest

As she celebrates the 30th anniversary of her soap debut, Laura Wright (Carly) reflected on the path that led her to GH as a guest on Digest’s podcast, Dishing With Digest.

9 mins read
Soap Opera Digest
October 18, 2021

DAYS: THE DEVIL WANTS BEN AND CIARA'S BABY

Ben is still on the fence about having a child, so he turns to Marlena for guidance. “He’s got mixed feelings about it because of his genetics and his family,” explains Robert Scott Wilson (Ben).

2 mins read
Soap Opera Digest
October 18, 2021

Catching Up With…Darcy Rose Byrnes (ex-Abby Newman, Y&R, 2003-08)

If you’ve ever caught the YouTube video of a very young Darcy Rose Byrnes singing “The Wizard And I” from her all-time favorite musical, Wicked, she respectfully requests that you disregard that it’s Elphaba’s song.

7 mins read
Soap Opera Digest
October 18, 2021

SOUND OFF

What's on your mind?

4 mins read
Soap Opera Digest
October 18, 2021

Y&R: ASHLAND HAS DOUBTS ABOUT THE WEDDING

At the Newman palazzo, Victoria finalizes wedding details with Ashland, who is having trouble keeping his mind on the preparations. He finally asks his bride if she truly wants to go through with the wedding after learning the truth about his past.

2 mins read
Soap Opera Digest
October 18, 2021

Y&R'S MICHAEL MEALOR AND HUNTER KING ON “SKYLE” RETURN

Michael Mealor and Hunter King have similar sentiments about reprising their roles as Y&R’s popular Kyle and Summer.

5 mins read
Soap Opera Digest
October 18, 2021

2022 MOTORTREND SUV OF THE YEAR

THE BEST GENESIS VEHICLE EVER PUTS AN ENTIRE LUXURY SUV SEGMENT ON NOTICE GENESIS GV70

8 mins read
Motor Trend
December 2021