Try GOLD - Free
Legal opinion supports Kohler-Barnard’s participation
The Star
|October 17, 2025
THE legal advice obtained by the DA says there is no basis for the party's MP, Dianne Kohler-Barnard, to excuse herself or be removed from the parliamentary inquiry into allegations of corruption in the criminal justice.
The DA sought the legal opinion after KZN police commissioner Nhlanhla Mkhwanazi accused Kohler-Barnard of disclosing classified intelligence information at the parliamentary inquiry and Madlanga Commission, an allegation she has denied. She has been under pressure from the ANC, MK Party, the Patriotic Alliance and ActionSA to excuse herself or be removed.
During the meeting of the Ad Hoc Committee on Wednesday night, DA MP Glynnis Breytenbach said the conclusion reached by their legal advice was that there was no factual basis to conclude that Kohler-Barnard was biased, conflicted and could not participate in the inquiry.
She said the rules of the National Assembly and the code of conduct required an MP to withdraw when issues were considered or decided upon. The legal opinion said available facts showed that Kohler-Barnard did not reveal any information she obtained as result of her membership of the Joint Standing Committee on Intelligence.
She also, says the legal opinion, did not reveal information about the Crime Intelligence information that was not already in public domain, but she was the first to disclose information about the purchase of Berea property in Durban, including the address.
This story is from the October 17, 2025 edition of The Star.
Subscribe to Magzter GOLD to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 10,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
MORE STORIES FROM The Star
The Star
Jill Scott returns to neo-soul with new album after decade-long wait
JILL
1 mins
January 07, 2026
The Star
Mayor Moya appointed to drive climate action strategies
MAYOR of Tshwane Nasiphi Moya, a newly-appointed commissioner for the Presidential Climate Commission (PCC) for the 2026-2030 term, says the city will contribute its hand-on experience and data-driven approaches to the commission's work to drive impactful climate strategies.
2 mins
January 07, 2026
The Star
Who stood out for South Africa at AFCON
BAFANA Bafana’s Africa Cup of Nations campaign came to an abrupt end in the round of 16, offering moments of promise alongside clear areas for growth.
2 mins
January 07, 2026
The Star
Legal battle to publish matric results
IR believes learners could receive their results from schools or be notified via SMS
2 mins
January 07, 2026
The Star
Gunners are throwing a title party while rivals misplace the invite
WE’RE at the halfway point of the English Premier League season and the only wobble coming from league leaders Arsenal is in the leftover jelly from one festive meal too many.
2 mins
January 07, 2026
The Star
Two major SA stars involved in car accidents: here’s how they are doing now
AWARD-winning artist Makhadzi has been discharged from hospital after a car accident that occured while she was travelling from Limpopo to Johannesburg late last month.
1 mins
January 07, 2026
The Star
Acsa slams claims of security capacity gaps amid allegations of staff poaching
AIRPORTS Company South Africa (Acsa) has dismissed allegations that it lacks the capacity to manage security checkpoints at its airports, particularly passenger and baggage screening points, following reports that the entity has been informally recruiting private security staff to plug staffing gaps.
2 mins
January 07, 2026
The Star
While today feels fixed, tomorrow is still ours to shape
FORMER President Thabo Mbeki warned that we sometimes believe today is unchanging, forgetting that tomorrow brings difference.
3 mins
January 07, 2026
The Star
Unions warn of showdown with govt as Transalloys lays off workers over power costs
LABOUR unions are warning of an impending confrontation with government over the urgent setting and implementation of new electricity tariffs for ferrochrome smelters, after Transalloys has become the latest company to issue a retrenchment notice amid persistently high power costs.
2 mins
January 07, 2026
The Star
Manufacturing slips to 11-month low, weak demand drags sentiment
S&P Global says headline PMI declined to 47.7 in December, from 49.0 in November
2 mins
January 07, 2026
Listen
Translate
Change font size
