Try GOLD - Free

THE STRATEGIC BLUNDERS THAT SHAPED INDIA'S DESTINY

The Northlines

|

15 MAY 2025

Was India's future compromised by decisions taken in the euphoria of independence? How different would our geopolitical landscape look today had our first Prime Minister applied strategic foresight over ideological romanticism? What price has India paid for missed opportunities at the hands of one man — Jawaharlal Nehru?

- BY P. MOHAN CHANDRAN

THE STRATEGIC BLUNDERS THAT SHAPED INDIA'S DESTINY

The freedom struggle produced several titanic leaders, but post-1947 governance demanded not just visionaries, but hard-nosed strategists. Unfortunately, Nehru's tenure, despite his global charm and domestic popularity, was marred by a string of strategic blunders whose aftershocks still shape India's foreign and security policy.

Surrendering India's Seat at the UN Security Council

In the early 1950s, the United States and its allies, alarmed by the Chinese Civil War and communist expansion, proposed India as a permanent member of the United Nations Security Council. This offer, backed by U.S. State Department cables (as referenced in the book Choices by Shivshankar Menon, former National Security Advisor), was made both before and after the People's Republic of China took control of mainland China in 1949.

In a letter dated August 2, 1955, Nehru dismissed the proposal, stating, "We cannot do anything which would not be agreeable to the People's Republic of China."

Instead of embracing a seat that would have enhanced India's global stature, Nehru deferred in favor of Beijing — a move that allowed China to eventually claim the seat and systematically oppose India's interests for decades to come, including blocking India's entry into the Nuclear Suppliers Group and shielding Pakistan-based terrorists from UN sanctions.

Rejecting the Accession of Balochistan

MORE STORIES FROM The Northlines

The Northlines

Budgam By-Election: NC, PDP yet to nominate candidates as deadline nears

As the last date for filing nomination papers for the Budgam by-election approaches, the two major regional parties including National Conference (NC) and Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) are yet to officially declare their candidates.

time to read

1 min

18 OCT 2025

The Northlines

Congress denies rift with NC, continues its support

Vows to block BJP’s agenda in J&K

time to read

1 min

18 OCT 2025

The Northlines

Ladakh Violence: MHA orders judicial probe by retired SC Judge BS Chauhan

‘Investigation will examine circumstances, deaths of 4 individuals’

time to read

1 min

18 OCT 2025

The Northlines

Rajya Sabha polls: All eyes on independents, but no one can see their vote

Opaque voting rules put spotlight on 7 non-party MLAs

time to read

1 mins

18 OCT 2025

The Northlines

The Northlines

Modi Govt’s tough stand on terror in J&K unmatched: Shah

‘During Congress rule, terrorists played Khoon Ki Holi across India’

time to read

1 mins

18 OCT 2025

The Northlines

Act responsibly and maintain peace: CS tells people of Ladakh

Leh, Oct 17: Chief Secretary of Ladakh, Dr Pawan Kotwal, on Friday urged the people to “act responsibly” and maintain peace in the aftermath of the Leh violence on September 24, which left four dead and several injured.

time to read

1 min

18 OCT 2025

The Northlines

Retaining wall collapse on NH disrupts traffic

Restoration work underway to reopen highway tube soon, says NHAI Project Director

time to read

1 min

18 OCT 2025

The Northlines

RO sends ballot to Kathua jail for MLA Mehraj Malik

The Returning Officer for the Rajya Sabha polls has sent postal ballot papers to the Superintendent of District Jail Kathua, where Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) MLA Mehraj Malik is detained under the Public Safety Act, 1978, to enable him to cast his vote.

time to read

1 min

18 OCT 2025

The Northlines

The Northlines

Gulchain Singh Charak passes away

NL CORRESPONDENT

time to read

1 min

18 OCT 2025

The Northlines

The Northlines

NC asks Congress to contest Nagrota Assembly seat, retains Budgam

‘CM says statehood will end Delhi alienation; CS panel progressing on daily wagers; All promises to be met in 5 years

time to read

1 min

18 OCT 2025

Listen

Translate

Share

-
+

Change font size