Go Unlimited with Magzter GOLD

Go Unlimited with Magzter GOLD

Get unlimited access to 10,000+ magazines, newspapers and Premium stories for just

$149.99
 
$74.99/Year

Try GOLD - Free

FOR GRACE IN LEGAL EVOLUTION

The New Indian Express Mangaluru

|

December 20, 2024

HE recent decision of a nine-judge bench of the Supreme Court, in Property Owners Association vs State of Maharashtra, which interprets Article 39(b) of the Constitution, represents a noteworthy development in the complex and often contentious history of property rights in India.

- SAAI SUDHARSAN SATHIYAMOOTHY

In deciding that not all private property forms part of the "material resources of the community" available for distribution by the state, the court has sought to achieve a nuanced balance between the conflicting demands of individual rights and the state's obligation to ensure economic justice for all.

The judgment, apart from exemplifying the SC's ever-evolving take on the characteristics and extent of property rights within a socialist democratic republic, is a reflection of the changing attitude of the ruling dispensation towards some conflicts that have underpinned this discourse since the inception of our republic.

In Property Owners, the court addressed a long-standing debate over the interpretation of Article 39(b), specifically the phrase "material resources of the community".

The judgment carries special significance for its potential impact on future legislation. It refutes the interpretation that all privately owned resources automatically fall under the ambit of "material resources of the community", an interpretation championed by Justice VR Krishna Iyer in the Ranganatha Reddy case and subsequently followed in the Sanjeev Coke case.

It clarifies that while private resources can be considered "material resources of the community" in specific contexts, this is not an automatic categorization. By rejecting this broad interpretation, the Court, in a way, reaffirms the importance of individual property rights while acknowledging the state's role in regulating resources for the common good.

The judgment, however, also has significant implications for judicial discipline and the treatment of minority opinions.

MORE STORIES FROM The New Indian Express Mangaluru

The New Indian Express Mangaluru

LINKING INDIA'S 2-SPEED ECONOMY

THE parallel analysis of some key indicators reveals a sharp and persistent divergence in India’s growth story. The Index of Industrial Production for September 2025, when combined with RBI’s Industrial Outlook Survey for July-September 2025, highlights a troubling conflict. Industrial growth is being vigorously driven by investment and capital goods, but is being held back by uneven household demand, particularly in mass-market segments.

time to read

3 mins

November 21, 2025

The New Indian Express Mangaluru

Real-time scam detection among Google’s new Safety initiatives

ager, Google India, said that Google is taking a 360-degree approach to safety - combining on-product and on-cloud protections, digital literacy to empower users with knowledge and awareness, and investing in continuous safety research so as to keep updating defences to keep up with the emerging threats.

time to read

1 mins

November 21, 2025

The New Indian Express Mangaluru

The New Indian Express Mangaluru

Newspaper office in Jammu raided, cops say weapons seized; 4 more in NIA net

THE National Investigation Agency (NIA) on Thursday formally took custody of four accused involved in the November 10 blast outside Red Fort in Delhi, taking the total number of arrests in the case to six.

time to read

2 mins

November 21, 2025

The New Indian Express Mangaluru

Stronger regional security network key in changing global order: Doval

NATIONAL Security Adviser Ajit Doval Thursday underscored the “significance” of strengthening regional partnerships amid a “rapidly changing and challenging global security environment,” as he opened the NSA-level meeting of the Colombo Security Conclave (CSC) in New Delhi.

time to read

1 mins

November 21, 2025

The New Indian Express Mangaluru

Vedic ritual for Ram temple flag hoisting today

THE Vedic rituals for the Dharm Dhwajaarohan (flag-hoisting) ceremony at the Ayodhya Temple will commence on Friday.

time to read

1 min

November 21, 2025

The New Indian Express Mangaluru

In 1st use of 1950 Act, Assam hunt for 'declared foreigners'

EXPULSION OF IMMIGRANTS

time to read

1 mins

November 21, 2025

The New Indian Express Mangaluru

ED files chargesheet against Vadra in laundering case linked to arms dealer

THE Enforcement Directorate (ED) filed a chargesheet on Thursday against Robert Vadra, businessman and brother-in-law of Rahul Gandhi, in a money laundering case linked to UK-based arms dealer Sanjay Bhandari.

time to read

1 min

November 21, 2025

The New Indian Express Mangaluru

MP faux pas: 3 dead teachers get 3 days to explain zero attendance

THREE government school teachers in Madhya Pradesh were recently sent show-cause notices for missing e-attendance. They’ll never respond—because the teachers are dead.

time to read

1 mins

November 21, 2025

The New Indian Express Mangaluru

India to see over 1 billion 5G subscriptions by 2031

TELECOM equipment maker Ericsson released its Mobility Report on Thursday, predicting that India will have more than 1 billion 5G subscriptions by the end of 2031, reaching 79% of total mobile subscriptions.

time to read

2 mins

November 21, 2025

The New Indian Express Mangaluru

The New Indian Express Mangaluru

No access to edu or health for 200 mn Indian kids

AROUND 206 million children in the country lack access to one of the six basic services— education, health, housing, nutrition, clean water and sanitation—which impact the quality of life and opportunities, said the UNICEF report released on Thursday.

time to read

1 mins

November 21, 2025

Listen

Translate

Share

-
+

Change font size