Go Unlimited with Magzter GOLD

Go Unlimited with Magzter GOLD

Get unlimited access to 9,500+ magazines, newspapers and Premium stories for just

$149.99
 
$74.99/Year

Try GOLD - Free

When Violence Is Built Into Logic Of Policy

The New Indian Express Hubballi

|

April 10, 2025

In social triage, the logic of numbers and idea of efficiency become more dominant in defining progress than death and displacement. We need to reinvent ethics for this age

- SHIV VISVANATHAN

remember teaching a class of post-graduate students, many of whom were potential IAS and IPS officers. My lecture was part of a course on development. I asked them what they thought was the genocidal count of an officer. They were aghast at the question. They saw themselves as a crusading group representing elite values. I asked how many people would they eliminate or displace through their careers: 10,000, 50,000 or a few lakhs. I added that the potential genocidal count of the class—in displacing villagers through dams, urban dwellers from slums and tribals from forests—could easily be 50,000.

The class was aghast at the potential report card of their future careers—that is, till I told them their social science was still innocent. It had no sense of the changing nature of violence. Their sense of violence was still the comic book idea of bully-meets-victim, without a sense that violence today is part of the very ontology of action, normalized to look like table manners.

This point was brought out poignantly by political philosopher Hannah Arendt in her book Eichmann in Jerusalem. Watching Adolf Eichmann, a Nazi Holocaust organizer, stand trial like an anonymous clerk made Arendt wonder how he could be responsible for the death of millions. Arendt quotes sociologist Bruno Bettelheim saying that he was less normal than Eichmann after meeting him. Eichmann explained he was merely taking orders as part of a hierarchy following a plan of action.

MORE STORIES FROM The New Indian Express Hubballi

The New Indian Express Hubballi

Vokkaliga seers want caste survey deferred

EVEN as Chief Minister Siddaramaiah stuck to his guns of conducting the Socioeconomic and Educational Survey, known as caste survey, from Monday, the Vokkaliga community leadership, including Adichunchanagiri Mutt head Sri Nirmalanandanatha Swamiji and Union Minister HD Kumaraswamy, here on Saturday issued a warning to the government, saying the survey is being carried out hastily for only fifteen days without addressing grievances of the community.

time to read

1 min

September 21, 2025

The New Indian Express Hubballi

Sports can no longer be a tool of diplomacy?

OVER the last few months, there has been a growing clamour for the Indian cricket team to refuse to play Pakistan and it grew before their first match in Asia Cup group stage.

time to read

1 min

September 21, 2025

The New Indian Express Hubballi

State forms SIT to probe Aland ‘voter deletions’

THE state government on Saturday formed a Special Investigation Team (SIT) to probe the alleged attempt to delete 6,018 names from the voters’ list in the Aland constituency of Kalaburagi district, ahead of the 2023 Assembly elections.

time to read

1 min

September 21, 2025

The New Indian Express Hubballi

2.8L Indian jobs on the line as Trump slaps $1L H-1B fee

THE Trump administration on Saturday imposed a fee of $1,00,000 per year on each H-1B visa holder, dealing a body blow to the 2,83,397 (71%) skilled technology workers from India, as per 2024 data. At 71%, India was the largest beneficiary of H-1B last year, while China was a distant second at 12%.

time to read

2 mins

September 21, 2025

The New Indian Express Hubballi

The New Indian Express Hubballi

I don't want you!

Stunned techies scramble to US, scrap fly out plan

time to read

1 min

September 21, 2025

The New Indian Express Hubballi

CM takes GBA engineers to task, sets Oct 31 deadline to fill potholes

ENRAGED over negative media reports highlighting the poor condition of roads, inconvenience to motorists and pedestrians, and protest by residents against the government, Chief Minister Siddaramaiah on Saturday warned engineers coming under Greater Bengaluru Authority (GBA) limits and set October 31 as deadline to make Bengaluru pothole-free.

time to read

1 min

September 21, 2025

The New Indian Express Hubballi

HINDENBURG ROW Sebi gives clean chit to Adani

MARKETS watchdog Sebi on Thursday dismissed all charges levelled by the now-shuttered US-based short-seller Hindenburg Research against the Adani group, its founder Gautam Adani, his brother, and a few top executives including group CFO Jugeshinder Singh.

time to read

1 min

September 19, 2025

The New Indian Express Hubballi

Fresh Rahul-CEC sparring on 'vote theft' in Karnataka

IN yet another exposé on 'vote theft', Congress leader Rahul Gandhi on Thursday claimed large-scale irregularities in Karnataka’s Aland constituency, accusing Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) Gyanesh Kumar of 'protecting those murdering democracy'.

time to read

1 mins

September 19, 2025

The New Indian Express Hubballi

Rift brewing in Cabinet over caste survey

WITH only a couple of days left for the state government’s ambitious caste survey to begin, the Cabinet seems to be divided over the issue as a section of ministers, reportedly, opposed the inclusion of 331 new castes in the survey list, including the ones which are opposed by the

time to read

1 min

September 19, 2025

The New Indian Express Hubballi

Guv returns amendment bill on lakes

IN a setback to the state government, Governor Thaawarchand Gehlot has returned the Karnataka Tank Conservation and Development Authority (Amendment) Bill, 2025, objecting to the government’s proposal to reduce the buffer zone around lakes from the existing 30 metre to between 3 and 24 metre, depending on the lake’s size.

time to read

1 min

September 16, 2025

Listen

Translate

Share

-
+

Change font size