Try GOLD - Free
Who seriously thinks the government's issues would be solved by a change of PM?
The Independent
|September 14, 2025
What a paradox. Angela Rayner had long been poised to seize Keir Starmer's crown, and yet the
moment she left the government, the speculation about his future intensified.
She was too canny a politician to show overt disloyalty, and had even taken in recent months to saying that she didn't want to be prime minister, but she was always the one that Starmer feared. All prime ministers worry about their job security more than outsiders think is justified. They imagine that they are going to be toppled at any moment, even when there are no outward signs of a threat to their position.
Suddenly, those inner fears are writ large in public, and Labour MPs are talking about when Starmer will go. The speculation is both vacuous froth and deeply damaging at the same time.
Who is the Labour MP who has said that Starmer “doesn’t seem up to the job” and that the party cannot carry on with him? It is Clive Lewis, a member of the 19-strong Socialist Campaign Group, which is always opposed to the leader, except when it was one of their own, Jeremy Corbyn.
And who is the Labour MP who is being touted in The Guardian as Starmer's replacement? It is Andy Burnham, the mayor of Greater Manchester, who is not an MP. For him to become an MP and therefore eligible to take over would require him to win a by-election, and I am not sure that there is any seat in the country in which a Labour candidate would be safe from Nigel Farage's party.
The closest Burnham is likely to get to No 10, it seems to me, would be getting Lucy Powell, his ally, elected as deputy leader of the party, which would give her a platform but no power.
This story is from the September 14, 2025 edition of The Independent.
Subscribe to Magzter GOLD to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 10,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
MORE STORIES FROM The Independent
The Independent
'We must do what we can to support those affected – so many must be frightened'
Philanthropist boosts The Independent's SafeCall campaign
2 mins
December 15, 2025
The Independent
Egypt hoping for a tourism boost from restored statues
Egypt has officially unveiled meticulously restored colossal statues of an ancient pharaoh in the southern city of Luxor – an event designed to bolster the nation’s vital tourism sector.
2 mins
December 15, 2025
The Independent
Fury after Met Police chief says shops need to ‘step up’
A retail boss has said he “could not believe” comments made by the head of the Metropolitan Police, calling on the industry to “step up and do better” to help stop shoplifting.
2 mins
December 15, 2025
The Independent
Fifteen people shot dead at Bondi Beach Jewish festival
Father, who was killed, and son, 24, carried out the assault
5 mins
December 15, 2025
The Independent
Ukraine can and will survive if its allies get serious quickly
We have the shadow of war knocking at Europe’s door, the armed forces minister Al Carns, the much-decorated Royal Marines veteran, explained in glorious mixed metaphor to assembled defence correspondents.
4 mins
December 15, 2025
The Independent
Belarus deploys cigarette balloons to rankle Lithuania
Officials say they have seized almost 40,000 packets of contraband from just 11 balloons in the last week alone
3 mins
December 15, 2025
The Independent
British rabbi among victims in Bondi Beach terror attack
A London-born rabbi has been named as one of the victims of the Bondi Beach terrorist attack, which claimed 16 lives.
1 mins
December 15, 2025
The Independent
Sacked minister demands explanation from Starmer
A Labour minister has publicly criticised Sir Keir Starmer after he received “no explanation” about why he was sacked from his cabinet role earlier this year - adding his wife was “furious” about the decision.
3 mins
December 15, 2025
The Independent
'Person of interest' held in Brown University shooting
A person of interest was in custody yesterday after a shooting during final exams at Brown University that killed two students and wounded nine others.
3 mins
December 15, 2025
The Independent
Bondi was my safe haven – now it will never be the same
When I woke up yesterday to learn there'd been yet another mass shooting in the US at Brown University with two dead, I was dismayed at my own lack of surprise - it could never happen here in Australia, I thought.
4 mins
December 15, 2025
Listen
Translate
Change font size
