Try GOLD - Free
What might a surrender deal for Hamas look like?
The Independent
|July 31, 2025
The demand by three Arab states that it put down its arms and leave Gaza is a strong diplomatic move but history suggests that expulsion rarely ends well, says Mark Almond

The horrors of Gaza have finally come to haunt the world's policymakers. Yesterday, the British government grasped at the talisman of recognising a Palestinian state without explaining how this might stop the violence.
Enter Qatar, Saudi Arabia and Egypt, three Arab countries that have demanded that Hamas now free the remaining Israeli hostages, lay down its arms and cease governing Gaza, for the sake of enabling Palestinian statehood and the chance of achieving a two-state solution.
Let's not get our hopes up. The trio have joined 14 other countries at a three-day conference at the United Nations in signing up to a French initiative that also requires Israel to agree to a ceasefire, end its blockade and recognise a Palestinian state in “all occupied Arab lands” - a point that is certain to be rejected by the current Israeli government since it means withdrawing from the West Bank and East Jerusalem where so many Jewish settlers live.
But having the Arab world call the very future of Hamas into question for the first time is a potential game-changer for the Middle East. It's certainly a nail in the coffin for the terrorist group.
This story is from the July 31, 2025 edition of The Independent.
Subscribe to Magzter GOLD to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 10,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
MORE STORIES FROM The Independent

The Independent
Liverpool wobble as Slot recalibrates stellar squad
Virgil van Dijk has built a career and a reputation on not panicking.
3 mins
October 02, 2025

The Independent
Starmer set to block return of Burnham to parliament
The PM would stop Burnham from entering any shortlists to become an MP, says minister (PA)
3 mins
October 02, 2025

The Independent
William was spied on by Daily Mail, High Court told
Information about the Prince of Wales’s 21st birthday party could have been “blagged” by a private investigator, it has been claimed at the High Court.
2 mins
October 02, 2025

The Independent
PM targets asylum rights to reduce UK's 'pull factors'
As he steps up attack on Farage, Starmer aims to reinterpret ECHR laws and toughen access for some migrants to Britain
5 mins
October 02, 2025

The Independent
Starmer chose the right time to confront intolerant Farage
There's a party game I've never played called Fuck, Marry, Kill. Before Labour conference, Keir Starmer will have been consulting with his closest advisers on how to play his own version of the game regarding Nigel Farage and Reform UK. This game is called “Accommodate, Confront, Ignore”.
3 mins
October 02, 2025

The Independent
Rochdale grooming gang leader sentenced to 35 years
A grooming gang leader who raped two girls in Rochdale has been sentenced to 35 years in prison.
1 mins
October 02, 2025

The Independent
How far should PM push the ‘Farage boats’ connection?
That “gently” delivered salvo is only the latest in what might be called Keir Starmer’s “barrage Farage” campaign.
3 mins
October 02, 2025

The Independent
What's behind Miliband's latest assault on fracking?
It may seem curious, but the energy secretary, Ed Miliband, safely playing out the last few hours of the Labour conference away from the media spotlight, has launched an attack on fracking, something that hasn't been seen in Britain since 2019.
2 mins
October 02, 2025

The Independent
SOFT OPTIONS
Daisy Lester picks the top winter cashmere jumpers
8 mins
October 02, 2025

The Independent
Keir's comrade: how Blair made a No 10 comeback
The former prime minister's influence on the current PM is everywhere, from AI to Gaza. But is that something about which we should be thankful or fearful?
7 mins
October 02, 2025
Listen
Translate
Change font size