Try GOLD - Free

Overrated Amorim's reign of error at United is over

The Independent

|

January 06, 2026

“I am a little bit of a dreamer,” smiled Ruben Amorim. “Call me naive, but I truly feel that I am the right man in the right moment.”

- RICHARD JOLLY

Overrated Amorim's reign of error at United is over

That was at his unveiling as Manchester United manager, before the dream turned into a nightmare, before naivety felt the least of his mistakes. As Amorim’s reign of error ends, it is apparent that it was the wrong moment for him. But also that he was the wrong man.

Amorim had the charisma to be United manager, just not the results, and a host of new candidates are already gathering. Old Trafford has been the theatre of broken dreams for the last dozen years, but if none of the men who followed Alex Ferguson could truly be called a success, none failed quite like Amorim. When United hired him, they felt he was the most exciting young coach in Europe. He left Sporting CP with a 100 per cent record in the Portuguese league and second in the Champions League. He left United with a 38.71 win percentage, comparable with those of Wilf McGuinness and Frank O’Farrell, and the possibility that he was their worst manager since the 1930s. In his parting press conference at Leeds on Sunday, he said that “every department needs to do their job”. Over 14 months, he did not do his remotely well enough.

image

MORE STORIES FROM The Independent

The Independent

The Independent

ON THIS DAY

1893: The Independent Labour Party was formed by Keir Hardie.

time to read

1 min

January 13, 2026

The Independent

The Independent

Sorry, trolls, autistic Barbie may be Mattel's best doll yet

From Barbie dolls with wheelchairs, canes, prosthetic legs and hearing aids; to blind Barbies and dolls with Down syndrome and type 1 diabetes - plus a Ken doll with vitiligo - playing with toys has come a long, long way since I last had a ragtag bunch of Barbie, Sindy and Jem dolls in the 1980s.

time to read

3 mins

January 13, 2026

The Independent

The Independent

WIRED AND HIRED

As recruitment teams are increasingly turning to elaborate AI-assisted screening techniques to find staff, Helen Coffey gets quizzed by an avatar and ponders the wider implications

time to read

8 mins

January 13, 2026

The Independent

The Independent

‘Port Talbot Pompeii’ find stuns archaeological team

Experts ‘strike gold’ with largest Roman villa discovery

time to read

3 mins

January 13, 2026

The Independent

The Independent

Zahawi 'begged for peerage before defecting to Reform

Controversial former Tory chancellor Nadhim Zahawi has defected to Reform UK after apparently unsuccessfully “begging” to be nominated for a peerage.

time to read

4 mins

January 13, 2026

The Independent

The Independent

Mitigation hearing starts in trial of Hong Kong activist

Supporters of Jimmy Lai had queued for days outside court

time to read

4 mins

January 13, 2026

The Independent

The Independent

Trump is playing with fire by attacking the Federal Reserve

Donald Trump says he did not know about the US Department of Justice’s threatened criminal prosecution of Federal Reserve chair Jerome Powell.

time to read

3 mins

January 13, 2026

The Independent

The Independent

NICE AND TOASTY

Rachael Penn snuggles up to the top electric heaters

time to read

11 mins

January 13, 2026

The Independent

The Independent

Should we explore Japan by car on our September trip?

Q We are planning a five-week trip to Japan in September. Bullet trains are the quickest way to get between major cities. However, in less populated areas, transport seems more difficult. As they drive on the same side of the road as us, we are thinking of hiring a car. Do you have any thoughts on this?

time to read

1 mins

January 13, 2026

The Independent

The Independent

What will former top Tory bring to his new party?

Former cabinet minister Nadhim Zahawi is the latest prominent Conservative to defect to Reform UK - to the obvious delight of its leader, Nigel Farage. Much is made of Zahawi’s expertise and experience, and he claims that he humbly wishes to be a “foot soldier” in Farage’s army because “we can all see that our beautiful, ancient, kind, magical island story has reached a dark and dangerous chapter”.

time to read

3 mins

January 13, 2026

Listen

Translate

Share

-
+

Change font size