Ministers will have 'blood on their hands' over IPP
The Independent
|December 05, 2025
Ex-top judge rails against 'unjust' indefinite jail terms
Britain’s former top judge has warned that ministers will have blood on their hands if they refuse to take action to help prisoners trapped in abolished indefinite jail terms.
John Thomas, a crossbench peer who served as head of the judiciary as lord chief justice from 2013 to 2017, told the prisons minister the government is failing those still trapped under “simply unjust” imprisonment for public protection (IPP) jail terms.
In a passionate speech in the House of Lords as peers debated a string of amendments to help IPP prisoners - which the government refused to support - he warned that more people would take their lives or die in prison while serving these sentences. At least 94 prisoners have died by suicide after losing hope of getting out.
The Independent has repeatedly called for all IPP prisoners to have their sentences - which have been branded “psychological torture” by the UN - reviewed.
Lord Thomas said: “If we don’t act now, we will have, and I use this word deliberately, blood on our hands. We cannot shirk the responsibility for rectifying an injustice. And what an injustice this is.”
The open-ended sentences were abolished in 2012, but not retrospectively. This has left thousands already sentenced incarcerated without a release date until they can convince the Parole Board they are safe to be released.
Victims of the scandal whose tragic cases have been highlighted by
This story is from the December 05, 2025 edition of The Independent.
Subscribe to Magzter GOLD to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 10,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
MORE STORIES FROM The Independent
The Independent
It's only flu' left me needing a double lung transplant
Three years ago, I found out the hard way just how crippling the flu can be.
4 mins
December 19, 2025
The Independent
Surely Villa can't keep up their illogical title challenge
It could amount to a triumph of reason. Arsenal top the Premier League table after seeming to plan for every eventuality, fill in every gap in the squad, take care of every small detail.
3 mins
December 19, 2025
The Independent
It betrays a lack of class to diss our taste for nostalgia
Earlier this week, a solicitor found herself at the centre of a minor internet firestorm after hosting what she described on social media as a “council estate dinner”.
4 mins
December 19, 2025
The Independent
Child intensive care cases rise as superflu floods wards
The number of children admitted to intensive care beds is on the rise as flu admissions to hospitals reach a record for this time of year.
2 mins
December 19, 2025
The Independent
BANANAS REPUBLIC
Cole Escola's hilarious Broadway smash, 'Oh Mary!', which imagines Abraham Lincoln's wife as a nightmarish clown, will delight audiences in London
2 mins
December 19, 2025
The Independent
Autism cases ‘will remain trapped despite law change’
Thousands of patients with learning disabilities will remain trapped in hospitals despite “milestone” changes to the Mental Health Act, campaigners have warned.
3 mins
December 19, 2025
The Independent
Bank drops interest rates to three-year low of 3.75%
Interest rates have been reduced to their lowest in nearly three years as Budget measures are set to push down on inflation, although the Bank of England cautioned that further cuts will be a “closer call”.
2 mins
December 19, 2025
The Independent
This will consign unfair and outdated treatment to history
For too long, our mental health laws have been a relic of another era. The 1983 Mental Health Act is older than many of the clinicians now working under it.
2 mins
December 19, 2025
The Independent
McIlroy ends 'dream year' by winning elusive trophy
Rory McIlroy ended the “year dreams are made of” by adding the Sports Personality of the Year award to his memorable triumphs at the Masters and Ryder Cup after being voted winner of the prestigious BBC prize for the first time.
3 mins
December 19, 2025
The Independent
Do you ever ignore Foreign Office advice on your trips?
Q You wrote about Guatemala’s tourism minister criticising the Foreign Office travel advice for his country. Do you scrupulously follow the rules, Simon?
1 mins
December 19, 2025
Listen
Translate
Change font size

