Try GOLD - Free
Israel vows Hamas will 'pay' for returning wrong body
The Independent
|February 22, 2025
Group denies deliberately handing over remains of unknown woman in place of Shiri Bibas but says 'mix-up' possible

Israel accused Hamas of handing over the remains of an unknown woman instead of an Israeli female hostage as bomb blasts rocked Tel Aviv in 24 hours of chaos that pushed the fragile ceasefire to the brink.
Israeli prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu vowed vengeance and warned the Palestinian militant group would pay “the full price” for what he called a “cruel and malicious violation of the agreement” after they failed to return the body of Shiri Bibas. Hamas admitted there was the possibility of a “mix-up” but said it had “no interest in retaining any bodies”, adding it had “demonstrated full compliance with the agreement”.
Last night Hamas released a body it said was that of Shiri Bibas. Israeli medical authorities said forensic teams were preparing to examine the remains, which Hamas transferred via the Red Cross.
Palestinian militants filmed a terrified Ms Bibas clutching her two children, Ariel, four, and Kfir, nine months, as she was seized during their 7 October 2023 attack on southern Israel. Her husband Yarden was also abducted, but was released in an earlier exchange this month. Ms Bibas and her boys were later killed.
The remains of Ariel and Kfir, as well as Oded Lifshitz, who was 83 when he was taken, were handed back to Israel on Thursday as part of the deal and positively identified, the Israeli military said. However, they said the fourth body was not that of the boys’ mother, nor of any other hostage.
Citing a forensic examination of the remains, Daniel Hagari, the military spokesperson, also accused Hamas of killing the children with “their bare hands” in November 2023. Hamas has repeatedly blamed Israel’s ferocious bombardment of Gaza for the deaths of Ms Bibas, her children and Mr Lifshitz. It denied intentionally handing over the wrong remains, adding it would “conduct a thorough review” of the allegations.
This story is from the February 22, 2025 edition of The Independent.
Subscribe to Magzter GOLD to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 10,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
MORE STORIES FROM The Independent

The Independent
Trump deserves praise for Gaza - if he sees it through
Go to Kosovo today, and among men in their mid-twenties you will find a disproportionate number of them named Tonibler.
4 mins
October 12, 2025

The Independent
Where should I go during Cambodia backpacker trip?
Q Friends have come back from Cambodia raving about the place as a backpacker destination. In your opinion, what highlights should I absolutely not miss?
1 mins
October 12, 2025

The Independent
A decade of pain before endometriosis is diagnosed
At just 12 years old, a terrified Zaynah Ahmed lost so much blood during her period that she was left in a life-threatening condition and needed an urgent blood transfusion.
3 mins
October 12, 2025
The Independent
BREAK THE SILENCE
Olivia Petter was made to feel she should ignore an incident with a stranger in a dressing room, but after bureaucratic hurdles and a police investigation, she finally felt vindicated
7 mins
October 12, 2025

The Independent
Hull KR thrash champions Wigan for Grand Final win
Hull KR completed an historic treble after battering defending champions Wigan 24-6 in a pulsating Super League Grand Final at Old Trafford.
2 mins
October 12, 2025

The Independent
Blair met Epstein while he was PM, documents reveal
Sir Tony Blair met with Jeffrey Epstein in Downing Street while he was prime minister, after lobbying from Peter Mandelson, documents have revealed.
2 mins
October 12, 2025

The Independent
Nobel Peace Prize winner dedicates award to Trump
Venezuelan opposition leader and the newly awarded Nobel Peace Prize winner has dedicated her win to Donald Trump for his “decisive support” in her country’s fight for democracy.
2 mins
October 12, 2025

The Independent
Fury as Taliban bars women from press event in India
The Taliban reportedly barred women journalists from attending a press event of visiting Afghan foreign minister Amir Khan Muttaqi in India, drawing anger from a wide section of Indian reporters, activists, and politicians.
4 mins
October 12, 2025

The Independent
'Here is ur diagnosis': Is this Labour's vision for the NHS?
Sitting in the middle of an office was not how I had ever envisaged being told that I have a long-term health condition, but that’s where I was when I received the following message - original typos included:
3 mins
October 12, 2025

The Independent
Starmer 'planning to blame Farage' for Budget tax hikes
Sir Keir Starmer is reportedly gearing up to blame Nigel Farage and Brexit for Britain’s expected downturn in productivity at the Budget, as part of a new attack on the Reform UK leader.
2 mins
October 12, 2025
Listen
Translate
Change font size