Try GOLD - Free
'I was jailed for six months because I am HIV-positive'
The Independent
|August 26, 2025
Robert Suttle was imprisoned after an ex-partner accused him of not disclosing his HIV status before they had sex. He tells Ellie Muir the law in some US states needs to change
I was 24 when I found out I was HIV-positive in 2003. I immediately went into a state of shock, and then a period of depression. But I pushed through to live a healthy and stable life, and began building my career as a legal clerk at the Court of Appeal, where I'm from in Louisiana.
But my life was turned upside down again on New Year's Eve, 2007. That night, I met a man at a gay club, and we ended up dating for three months. I immediately disclosed my HIV status to him, and I was in treatment at the time, which made my viral load low enough that I could not transmit HIV to another person. When the relationship ended badly, and we didn't see eye to eye on some things, he pressed charges against me, accusing me of not disclosing my status.
I did not transmit the virus to my former partner, but in Louisiana – one of the 33 states across the USA that have outdated HIV legislation first established in the Eighties and Nineties - the legal focus is on exposure. It does not require actual transmission for a conviction to occur.
I was arrested at my place of work in front of my colleagues. Upon the advice of my lawyer, I took a plea deal and was sentenced to six months in prison for the felony of "intentional exposure to the Aids virus".
This story is from the August 26, 2025 edition of The Independent.
Subscribe to Magzter GOLD to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 10,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
MORE STORIES FROM The Independent
The Independent
City's unpredictability tilts Champions League hopes
It is the sort of result that can mark a team out as potential champions of Europe. Beating Real Madrid in the Bernabeu, at the least, could offer an indication a team is equipped to defeat them in a final, semifinal or quarterfinal. Though, more than most, Pep Guardiola can testify to Real’s winning habit when the stakes are highest.
3 mins
December 12, 2025
The Independent
Villa on verge of qualifying after battling win at Basel
Second-half substitute Youri Tielemans hit the winner to help Aston Villa move a step closer to automatic qualification in the Europa League with a 2-1 win at Basel.
3 mins
December 12, 2025
The Independent
Trump's new foreign policy boils down to 'Americas first'
Unfortunately, in this case, “it” was not a toy, but an oil tanker that was boarded and captured in a military-led operation seen by much of the Western world as piracy.
3 mins
December 12, 2025
The Independent
How can I kill time between my flights in Guangzhou?
Q I have eight hours at Guangzhou airport in China between flights on a journey from Melbourne to London. I looked for some kind of lounge or hotel in the terminal where I could rest, but the price appeared to be around £100, which is a quarter of what I paid for the entire flight. Any suggestions?
1 mins
December 12, 2025
The Independent
The best movies of 2025
From 'Nosferatu' to 'Nickel Boys', Clarisse Loughrey picks her favourites after a tumultuous year for the industry
10 mins
December 12, 2025
The Independent
Blair commends Mahmood amid leadership speculation
Tony Blair has effectively endorsed Shabana Mahmood as a future Labour leader, praising her as “brilliant” and “impressive” in a joint public appearance with the home secretary. The former Labour prime minister hosted a Christmas event for the Tony Blair Institute (TBI) alongside Ms Mahmood, which she used to deliver a passionate personal and political manifesto.
5 mins
December 12, 2025
The Independent
How the US is preparing for possible war with Venezuela
Trump had 13 combat vessels in the region by November as Washington piles pressure on beleaguered President Maduro
3 mins
December 12, 2025
The Independent
People ask me if we think Andrew is alive or dead – it depends which day you ask
Kevin Gosden talks about the disappearance of his teenage son as he backs The Independent's SafeCall campaign
4 mins
December 12, 2025
The Independent
'I don't have many regrets in life, but that gives me cold sweats now and again'
Set to reprise the role that made him a household name for the long-awaited seventh season, Martin Compston talks to Katie Rosseinsky about 'Line of Duty' and his latest project
7 mins
December 12, 2025
The Independent
Holiday without a hangover
From booze-free bubbles to clever aperitifs, Rosamund Hall rounds up the very best no- and low-alcohol wines and drinks to see you through this festive season – minus the fuzzy head
5 mins
December 12, 2025
Listen
Translate
Change font size
