Try GOLD - Free

How England squandered a golden opportunity... again

The Independent

|

November 04, 2024

For England, it has become a familiar feeling. For the third time this year, Steve Borthwick’s side let a game slip from their grasp, squandering a golden opportunity to secure a rare win over the All Blacks as George Ford missed twice with his boot in the final minutes.

- HARRY LATHAM-COYLE

How England squandered a golden opportunity... again

After Mark Tele’a’s brilliant finish and Damian McKenzie’s superb touchline conversion nudged New Zealand ahead, Ford was handed a first chance to snatch victory from the tee as Anton Lienert-Brown was penalised for a high tackle.

When his penalty clanged back off the upright, that appeared to be that. Yet a Patrick Tuipulotu knock-on in contact gave England one last opportunity. It set up just about the perfect scenario from which to launch a match-winning play: a midfield scrum about 10 metres from the opposition line.

So what went wrong in the passage leading up to Ford’s miss? Here, The Independent analyses England’s errors in those final moments.

image1. The scrum

A worrying trend in England’s recent final-quarter collapses has been their failure to sustain a scrum effort across 80 minutes. It was apparent in their semi-final defeat to South Africa at last year’s World Cup, and their problems have not been solved since, even with varying personnel against an array of opposition.

The starting pack had fronted up well to a strong All Blacks scrummaging unit, with Ellis Genge and Will Stuart performing strongly at prop. But after the pair were replaced by rookie Fin Baxter and veteran Dan Cole, England began to creak, conceding a couple of penalties at the set piece. Mention must be given here to New Zealand’s replacements Pasilio Tosi and the outstanding Tuipulotu, who combined to add plenty of mass (260kg) and menace.

MORE STORIES FROM The Independent

The Independent

The Independent

I'm falling for a smoker... but I can't bear his filthy habit

The Indy's agony aunt Victoria Richards is here to help

time to read

3 mins

October 16, 2025

The Independent

The Independent

An unemployment tsunami is heading for older workers

The latest labour market data from the Office for National Statistics delivered a familiar array of nasties: unemployment up, vacancies down.

time to read

3 mins

October 16, 2025

The Independent

The Independent

Higher fliers: economy class on the Airbus upper deck

Simon Calder reveals the Airbus A380's cheap seats offering extra space, quicker service and a more intimate cabin

time to read

2 mins

October 16, 2025

The Independent

The Independent

‘Just adopt,’ they say. But what if you don’t want to?

Jennifer Aniston has admitted that after IVF failed, she preferred not to try adoption.

time to read

5 mins

October 16, 2025

The Independent

The Independent

UK sanctions Russia's oil giants and 'shadow fleet'

The UK government has imposed sanctions on Russia's largest oil producer, Rosneft, as part of its latest economic measures targeting Moscow amid the ongoing war in Ukraine.

time to read

3 mins

October 16, 2025

The Independent

The Independent

‘Marty knew that I would paint an honest portrait’

The peerless American filmmaker is the subject of a new documentary series. Louis Chilton speaks to the director of ‘Mr Scorsese’, Rebecca Miller, about his life and work

time to read

5 mins

October 16, 2025

The Independent

The Independent

Who makes the plane for England's World Cup bid?

Lawrence Ostlere on Tuchel's embarrassment of riches

time to read

5 mins

October 16, 2025

The Independent

The Independent

No 10 releases three China spy case witness statements

Evidence claims China conducts 'large-scale' UK espionage

time to read

4 mins

October 16, 2025

The Independent

The Independent

Minister, gimmicky language rules won't stop those boats

Shabana Mahmood has made a good start at the Home Office, saying the right things about regaining control of Britain’s borders and starting to deliver some policy changes.

time to read

2 mins

October 16, 2025

The Independent

The Independent

Taliban's bloody revenge on Afghans abandoned by UK

Holly Bancroft, Jessica Purkiss, Fahim Abed and May Bulman verify the killings of more than 100 ex-Afghan forces since 2023, one of whom was executed in front of his children

time to read

8 mins

October 16, 2025

Listen

Translate

Share

-
+

Change font size