Try GOLD - Free
Grey-Thompson says right to die will be open to abuse
The Independent
|November 21, 2024
Sporting hero and disability rights campaigner says loopholes in the assisted dying bill mean there are no real safeguards
Tanni Grey-Thompson has warned that if parliament passes a law allowing assisted dying it will enable unscrupulous families to go “doctor shopping” to end the lives of elderly, disabled or sick relatives.
The 11-time Paralympic gold medallist, now a disability rights campaigner and member of the House of Lords, spoke exclusively to The Independent about her fears of the consequences if MPs and peers pass the controversial legislation.
The private members bill brought forward by Labour MP Kim Leadbeater is due to have its second reading in the Commons on 29 November. But already both ministers who will be responsible for overseeing its implementation if it is passed – health secretary Wes Streeting and justice secretary Shabana Mahmood – have indicated that they will oppose the legislation.
Baroness Grey-Thompson dismisses claims by Ms Leadbeater and her supporters that the bill contains the strictest safeguards in the world, warning that “the reality ... is very different”. The cross-bench peer’s intervention comes after a warning from Sir James Munby, former president of the family division of the High Court, who also raised serious concerns about the bill’s safeguards.
In a forthright interview, she questions the myths behind assisted dying and highlights the loopholes in the bill, which she believes will open the floodgates to abuse. She argues that Section 4 (5) of the bill means that if one doctor refuses to sign a request, another can then be found who will – as two doctors and a judge are needed to provide permission for the procedure.This story is from the November 21, 2024 edition of The Independent.
Subscribe to Magzter GOLD to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 10,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
MORE STORIES FROM The Independent
The Independent
‘At the edge of catastrophe’
With a ceasefire between Israel and Hezbollah in tatters, aid agencies are warning Lebanon is facing a humanitarian crisis
4 mins
May 03, 2026
The Independent
‘What will make me want to get up in the morning?’
Sarah Parish has become one of the most watchable actors on British TV, but she’s just as passionate about theatre, she tells Patrick Smith as her new play ‘Eclipse’ opens in Chichester
7 mins
May 03, 2026
The Independent
This road trip tells the story of Britain’s oldest border
Richard Collett finds spectacular landscapes and ancient ruins on a 160-mile journey between England and Wales
5 mins
May 03, 2026
The Independent
‘Climate change is changing the landscape of poverty’
Christian Aid CEO Patrick Watt tells Nick Ferris how floods, extreme weather, spiralling sovereign debt, and the Iran war all pose a threat to the fight against poverty around the world
4 mins
May 03, 2026
The Independent
Badenoch issues apology for use of Bloody Sunday clip
Kemi Badenoch has issued an apology after footage depicting Bloody Sunday was used in a social media clip criticising a proposed bill on Northern Ireland legacy issues.
1 mins
May 03, 2026
The Independent
Twins born minutes apart discover they’re half-sisters
A pair of twin sisters have discovered they have different fathers in what is believed to be a first in the UK.
2 mins
May 03, 2026
The Independent
Will Britain relax travel rules for Dubai and Doha?
Q Do you think the Foreign Office will relax its advice on the UAE and Qatar, at least to allow connecting from one flight to another?
1 mins
May 03, 2026
The Independent
Gyokeres double boosts Arsenal title hopes
Gunners open a six-point lead at the top of the table
2 mins
May 03, 2026
The Independent
‘It’s not the old Labour’: red wall town may fall to Farage
Voters in the former industrial powerhouse of St Helens – which is being eyed up by Reform – say they feel abandoned
6 mins
May 03, 2026
The Independent
‘I don’t know why anyone would open a pub any more’
Many pubs, restaurants and hotel companies will see their costs increase this month. Alex Ross spoke to celebrity chef Tom Kerridge as fears grows over the future for the industry
6 mins
May 03, 2026
Listen
Translate
Change font size
