Try GOLD - Free
Farage's deportation plans unworkable, say experts
The Independent
|September 23, 2025
Care industry warns of huge labour shortages under proposal

Tens of thousands of people who have legally settled in Britain could be at risk of deportation under plans by Reform UK to scrap the main route towards British citizenship - a policy that was immediately dismissed as “an unworkable stunt based on dodgy maths”.
Nigel Farage said the current option of indefinite leave to remain - open to those who have lived and worked in Britain for five years - has “betrayed democracy” and vowed to abolish it.
The plans were condemned by migration charities and think tanks, as well as the care industry, which warned of crippling labour shortages.
Doubt was also cast over Mr Farage’s claim that savings from the policy would be “considerably larger” than the £230bn once suggested by the Centre for Policy Studies (CPS), despite the think tank having since said its figure should no longer be used.
And despite the Reform leader’s claims the proposals would cut Britain’s welfare bill, it has emerged that EU citizens would be exempted from plans to ban all migrants from receiving benefits. This means only 2.7 per cent of universal credit claimants would be affected by Reform’s clampdown.
Josephine Whitaker-Yilmaz, head of advocacy at charity Praxis, warned the proposals would “tank our already-struggling economy, by disrupting the lives of millions of people who’ve been living and working legally in the UK for many years”.
Ben Brindle, a researcher at the Migration Observatory at the University of Oxford, questioned Mr Farage’s statement that half of those who have migrated to the UK are not working.
This story is from the September 23, 2025 edition of The Independent.
Subscribe to Magzter GOLD to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,500+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
MORE STORIES FROM The Independent

The Independent
Without concrete action, there won't be any Palestine left for Britain to recognise
Watershed moment may be pointless unless Israel is deterred from annexing the occupied West Bank
3 mins
September 23, 2025

The Independent
Gatwick is squeezing every last ounce from its runway
“Doing nothing is not an option”: that was what the last transport secretary but a dozen, Alistair Darling, told me on a visit to Gatwick airport in 2004. He was referring to the discussion about extra aviation capacity for the southeast of England.
2 mins
September 23, 2025

The Independent
'I'm not a stranger, I'm part of the UK's everyday story'
Migrants who have made a life in Britain share their fears about Farage's controversial deportation plan.
3 mins
September 23, 2025

The Independent
Horner's F1 return may be speedy after bumper payout
Christian Horner has received a reported payout of more than £80m from Red Bull after officially leaving the company yesterday.
2 mins
September 23, 2025

The Independent
Potter awaits Hammer blow as anger stalks east London
So it turns out the West Ham fans were wrong. “Sacked in the morning,” they chanted to Graham Potter during Saturday’s home defeat to Crystal Palace. But he has made it past the weekend.
4 mins
September 23, 2025

The Independent
UK activist to be freed after six years in Egyptian prison
Egyptian president Abdel Fattah al-Sisi has pardoned British-Egyptian activist Alaa Abd el-Fattah after six years.
2 mins
September 23, 2025

The Independent
How we've chosen our son's welfare over our principles
A mother who thinks the private school system is wrong, but pays for a tutor for her child who fell behind in class, explains how she fears she has become a middle-class hypocrite
5 mins
September 23, 2025

The Independent
Common painkiller Tylenol causes autism, says Trump
President Donald Trump and health and human services secretary Robert F Kennedy Jr last night claimed there was a link between autism and acetaminophen, commonly known as Tylenol, despite little or no evidence to back the claim.
4 mins
September 23, 2025

The Independent
Farage's deportation plans unworkable, say experts
Care industry warns of huge labour shortages under proposal
4 mins
September 23, 2025

The Independent
Labour is content to watch the climate crash and burn
Labour has approved a second runway at Gatwick airport.
3 mins
September 23, 2025
Listen
Translate
Change font size