Try GOLD - Free
Blairites are in despair over Starmer's flailing leadership
The Independent
|December 01, 2024
Someone close to Tony Blair says that Keir Starmer's problem, apart from the fact that his ministers and aides are not very good, is that they are "a bunch of librarians and academics in charge of a government".

This may be unfair to librarians and academics, but we know what is meant. I am told that this person thinks that Starmer’s government is unimaginative and out of touch; that it lacks the “dexterity” to manage the daily crises that besiege 10 Downing Street, and that there isn’t much diversity of thought at the top of government, that “they all think the same”.
There is a plodding, bookish other-worldliness about the government that worries a lot of Blairites – although Blair himself remains sphinx-like in his inscrutability.
Some of his acolytes say that although Starmer’s aides admire the prime minister’s ruthlessness, they are confusing ruthless sackings (Sue Gray, Louise Haigh) and the macho adoption of hardcore “Blairite” positions (such as on immigration) with a clear sense of purpose communicated to the public and pursued single-mindedly.
Not that “the Blairites” are a united bloc. Many of them, indeed, are working for Starmer. Morgan McSweeney, his most important adviser, is no conventional Blairite, but he has Peter Mandelson’s blessing as a tough centrist operator. Matthew Doyle, Starmer’s head of communications, has been with him for years and is New Labour through and through. The cabinet is stuffed with Blairites: Pat McFadden, Wes Streeting, Liz Kendall, Peter Kyle, Steve Reed, Ian Murray, Angela Smith (the leader in the Lords) and now Heidi Alexander, the new transport secretary.
This story is from the December 01, 2024 edition of The Independent.
Subscribe to Magzter GOLD to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 10,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
MORE STORIES FROM The Independent

The Independent
There was an alchemy...
Film's master of twist - M Night Shyamalan - has teamed up with literature's maestro of romance – Nicholas Sparks – for a new project that comprises a book and a movie adaptation. Louis Chilton talks to them about collaboration with a twist
6 mins
October 14, 2025

The Independent
Sorry, no one wants to see The Inbetweeners as adults
The original only worked because it perfectly captured the experience of being a British teenager in the Noughties, writes Helen Coffey, who has had her fill of reboots
4 mins
October 14, 2025

The Independent
Reform council leader vows to 'lie in front of bulldozers'
Party has been vocal about its opposition to net zero plans
2 mins
October 14, 2025

The Independent
Allen misses out on a night carrying a brutal reminder
Late on Saturday night, in front of 10,000 howling fans in Sheffield, Dave Allen fell short in his bold attempt to move up the heavyweight rankings.
3 mins
October 14, 2025

The Independent
'How long we dreamt of this day': joy and pain of families and those released after deal
Very different homecomings for freed Israeli hostages and Palestinian prisoners were witnessed by Bel Trew in Tel Aviv, Rateb al-Qaissy in Ramallah and Nedal Hamdouna in Gaza
4 mins
October 14, 2025

The Independent
World hunger is a political choice – just look at Brazil
Hunger is neither a natural condition of humankind nor an unavoidable tragedy: it is the result of choices made by governments and economic systems that have chosen to turn a blind eye to inequality or even promote it.
3 mins
October 14, 2025

The Independent
Marinating in the milk and honey of Israeli hyperbole
As you might expect, the “sermon near the Mount”, as delivered by Donald Trump to the Knesset in Jerusalem, was less a case of “Blessed are the peacemakers for they will be called the sons of God” as “Blessed are you lot to have me, and you will call me your peacemaker.”
3 mins
October 14, 2025

The Independent
Robinson had thousands in cash when held at border
Asked for his phone PIN, activist said: 'Not a chance, bruv'
2 mins
October 14, 2025

The Independent
Tuchel urges Rashford to add consistency to ability
The England manager warns his striker to take the 'right decisions' to prevent later regret
3 mins
October 14, 2025
The Independent
Trump must learn patience for Gaza peace to endure
The hostages are free. That – not the bombastic and performative speech given to the Knesset by Donald Trump, or the self-congratulatory and ingratiating performance by the prime minister of Israel, Benjamin Netanyahu - was the most important event of a historic day.
3 mins
October 14, 2025
Listen
Translate
Change font size