Try GOLD - Free
Amorim wins 3-4-2-1 battle but his system is still flawed
The Independent
|December 01, 2025
Perhaps for the first time in his Manchester United tenure, a 34-2-1 worked well for Ruben Amorim. Not his own specifically; more the fact that Crystal Palace manager Oliver Glasner also chooses to deploy that system.
While Amorim's iteration has been the subject of plenty of debate, Glasner's has often been praised, but it was the Portuguese who came out as the victor this time around as United secured a 2-1 win over the Eagles courtesy of goals from Joshua Zirkzee and Mason Mount.
Amorim came into the game under plenty of scrutiny after sticking to his formation in the dismal loss to Everton despite the Toffees having 10 men, while Glasner enjoys full backing at Palace after delivering the first trophy in the club's history with the FA Cup win last year.
But while any formation and all tactics can have merits at different times, this match was not an advert for the merits of a 3-4-2-1.
The visitors almost got off to a dream start when a long throw caused problems in the Palace box, with a brilliant save from Dean Henderson denying Casemiro from point-blank range.However, from there United offered precious little, again relying - as is often the case these days - on a lucky break, a counter or a set-piece to create anything in attack.
At the same time, Palace were quick to create their own opportunities, the home crowd gaining plenty of encouragement as Jean-Philippe Mateta found the side-netting before dragging an effort wide a few minutes later, the Frenchman having gone clean through after a fortunate ricochet off Leny Yoro.
Mateta knew he should have opened the scoring but he didn't need to wait long to do so anyway, winning a penalty and converting it not once but twice, after a VAR review showed he touched the ball twice on the first effort.

This story is from the December 01, 2025 edition of The Independent.
Subscribe to Magzter GOLD to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 10,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
MORE STORIES FROM The Independent
The Independent
Salah returns to Liverpool squad after talks with Slot
Mohamed Salah will return to the Liverpool squad against Brighton today after holding peace talks with manager Arne Slot.
1 mins
December 13, 2025
The Independent
‘You have to pay for what you used to get for free’
Kiefer Sutherland talks to Louis Chilton about his Christmas comedy 'Tinsel Town', the 'ironic' state of modern television, and why his acting style is so different from that of his father
7 mins
December 13, 2025
The Independent
A strong economy is Britain's best defence against Putin
Imagine it, said Mark Rutte, secretary general of Nato, in his speech in Berlin on Thursday: “A conflict reaching every home, every workplace; destruction, mass mobilisation, millions displaced, widespread suffering and extreme losses.
3 mins
December 13, 2025
The Independent
SATURDAY QUIZ
Chris Maume presents his weekly general knowledge quiz
1 min
December 13, 2025
The Independent
Reform UK now the largest party in Britain, says Farage
Nigel Farage has claimed that Reform UK is now Britain’s biggest political party after an internal leak suggested that Labour has lost 100,000 members.
2 mins
December 13, 2025
The Independent
Impressionist and comedian Stanley Baxter dies, aged 99
Glaswegian star was considered a pioneer in world of satire
4 mins
December 13, 2025
The Independent
Church warns against fake 'banned Christmas' claims ahead of Robinson rally
A senior bishop in the Church of England has hit out at fake claims that “Christmas has been cancelled” and criticised those seeking to politicise Christianity ahead of a carols event organised by anti-migrant activist Tommy Robinson.
3 mins
December 13, 2025
The Independent
Get a jab, or a mask, to keep your loved ones safe from flu
I wouldn't want to sound smugger than I usually do, but I got my flu vaccination many weeks ago, just as I did with my Covid booster.
3 mins
December 13, 2025
The Independent
Briton jailed for killing man in drunken e-scooter crash
A British backpacker who struck and killed a pedestrian while riding an e-scooter while drunk in central Perth has been sentenced to four years in prison.
2 mins
December 13, 2025
The Independent
Details of Machado's daring escape to Norway revealed
Maria Corina Machado used a wig and disguise to sneak through 10 military checkpoints in Venezuela during a perilous three-day journey to the Nobel Peace Prize ceremony in Norway.
2 mins
December 13, 2025
Listen
Translate
Change font size
