Try GOLD - Free
A smooth Six Nations may be thorn in Red Roses side
The Independent
|March 22, 2025
Real challenge is needed to avoid another World Cup tragedy
As richly rewarding a competition as it may be, the start of the Women’s Six Nations can sometimes be an exercise in finding new ways to ask the same old questions. For several years now, we have yearned for a challenger to rise and take on the Red Roses, to meet the might of rugby’s most dominant side, but six editions into their tournament monopoly, the prospect of a nonEnglish winner has never felt more distant.
That is not, at all, the fault of John Mitchell and his side, whose relentless pursuit of greatness, and the World Cup crown that eludes them, is evidenced by a switch of captain in what may prove a defining year. But it does mean that the lines of enquiry required when talking to the best and the rest are subtly different.
For instance, after unveiling his side to face Italy in York on Sunday at a Twickenham pub, Mitchell was probed on how he would weigh lopsided scorelines in the selection shake-up for a World Cup which is now hurtling into view. The enviable squad depth possessed by England creates unenviable headaches for their head coach, with as many as 40-45 worthy players having to be narrowed to 32 come the ultimate prize in August and September.
Narrowing down one’s options when you may not face a true test until the meeting with France on the final Saturday will not be easy. If that feels dismissive of England’s opposition, it is worth remembering that the Red Roses have won 50 of their last 51 games (with that harrowing World Cup final defeat the lone exception) and not lost on home soil in this tournament for a decade.

This story is from the March 22, 2025 edition of The Independent.
Subscribe to Magzter GOLD to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 10,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
MORE STORIES FROM The Independent
The Independent
Women’s flexibility trap
Visibility is only part of the problem as flexible working roles that pay less compound wealth issues
3 mins
March 08, 2026
The Independent
‘You will know in your heart that Romford is in Essex’
Bryony Gooch and Shaheena Uddin talk to Havering locals, who are divided on the subject of leaving Greater London
5 mins
March 08, 2026
The Independent
Sublime Scotland shatter France’s grand slam dreams
Scotland put themselves in contention for a first-ever Six Nations title with a sensational seven-try, 50-40 victory over France at Murrayfield.
2 mins
March 08, 2026
The Independent
Who's in the frame to pay?
The UK's free museums are in trouble, so should tourists start paying? Annabel Nugent explores the fraught debate about who should foot the bill for keeping them on the house
8 mins
March 08, 2026
The Independent
Child killer Huntley dies after attack by fellow inmate
Ian Huntley, the notorious Soham murderer and one of Britain’s most reviled killers, has died following a vicious prison attack.
3 mins
March 08, 2026
The Independent
I quit the Foreign Office in disgust at what it has become
I resigned earlier this week from the Foreign Office after 11 years in the diplomatic service.
3 mins
March 08, 2026
The Independent
‘Women’s Day is a time to refocus on opportunities’
Indhu Rubasingham made history when she became the first woman and the first person of colour to lead the National Theatre. Ms Rubasingham speaks about the importance of International Women's Day as she appears on The Independent's Influence List.
1 min
March 08, 2026
The Independent
Past hidden in plain sight
After 18 years of living in Athens, Rebecca Hall has found that some of the city's most impressive artefacts aren't in museums, but are woven into its very fabric – and free to visit
4 mins
March 08, 2026
The Independent
Gulf airspace closure leaves travellers stranded overseas
How will Middle East airlines ever rebuild confidence after flight chaos leaves passengers grounded
3 mins
March 08, 2026
The Independent
Sultry disco-pop takes on sparkling new dimensions
Harry Styles knows how to control a screaming Manchester audience as he celebrates his new album
3 mins
March 08, 2026
Listen
Translate
Change font size
