Try GOLD - Free
Letby lawyer seeks fresh appeal over reliability of expert witness
The Guardian
|December 17, 2024
Lucy Letby's lawyer has said he is seeking to reopen her appeal because the prosecution's lead medical expert witness, Dr Dewi Evans, has "changed his mind" on some key evidence.
At a press conference yesterday, Mark McDonald said Evans was "not a reliable expert" and that all the convictions were not safe.
"Today the defence is announcing that it will immediately seek permission from the court of appeal to take the exceptional, but necessary, decision to apply to reopen the appeal of Lucy Letby and immediately review all her convictions," McDonald said.
He also gave details of new medical expert reports produced for the former nurse's defence by two consultant neonatologists, which wholly dispute the prosecution evidence for two of the babies Letby was convicted of killing.
The experts' report into one of the babies, Baby O, alleges that a doctor caused the baby to die by, apparently mistakenly, pressing a needle into the liver while trying to relieve excess air in the stomach.
Richard Taylor, a consultant neonatologist based in Victoria, British Columbia, who is one of approximately 100 medical and other experts now assisting Letby with her defence, said that the doctor at the hospital, whom McDonald did not name, must have been aware he had done so.
This story is from the December 17, 2024 edition of The Guardian.
Subscribe to Magzter GOLD to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 10,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
MORE STORIES FROM The Guardian
The Guardian
'Bereavement penalty' blamed for premium rises
Shortly after her husband died, Kay Lawley* received renewal quotes from the couple's home and car insurance provider, Ageas. She told the company of his death and was stunned that the quotes then increased by up to 15%.
3 mins
November 15, 2025
The Guardian
US planning divided Gaza controlled by troops
The US is planning for the long-term division of Gaza into a “green zone” under Israeli and international military control, where reconstruction would start, and a “red zone” to be left in ruins.
5 mins
November 15, 2025
The Guardian
Who would want an impossible job?
Davie's successor must face political storm and claims of enemy within
5 mins
November 15, 2025
The Guardian
Workers face £7.5bn rise in tax despite Reeves U-turn
Rachel Reeves will raise £7.5bn from millions of workers in the budget by freezing tax thresholds, after her decision to scrap controversial plans to raise income tax led to a selloff in the bond market.
4 mins
November 15, 2025
The Guardian
Doctors' strikes With BMA and Streeting poles apart, pay row has no end in sight
As resident doctors began a new round of industrial action yesterday, it felt very like the other 49 days of strikes since March 2023, with medics on picket lines outside hospitals across England in a battle for public sympathy.
4 mins
November 15, 2025
The Guardian
Theatre review Ambika Mod excels in tale of grim addiction
\"It's not that deep,\" Ani's friend assures her. Who cares if she watches a lot of extreme pornography?
2 mins
November 15, 2025
The Guardian
'They all think Keir is done' Would-be Labour leaders jostle for position
If there's one thing the Labour party can agree on this week, it is that efforts by Keir Starmer's allies to shore up his position have backfired spectacularly.
5 mins
November 15, 2025
The Guardian
Reputation management The efforts to clean up sex offender's public image
Jeffrey Epstein and his associates worked to suppress negative press and rebuild his image in the years after he pleaded guilty in 2008 to state charges in Florida of solicitation of prostitution and of solicitation of prostitution with a minor, newly released documents reveal.
4 mins
November 15, 2025
The Guardian
The dangers of pellets used to clean up water
The millions of toxic plastic beads that washed up on to Camber Sands in East Sussex a few days ago have put wildlife at risk in what the local MP has called an “environmental catastrophe”.
2 mins
November 15, 2025
The Guardian
Revenue raising
Hard sells and low fruit to refill chancellor's coffers
2 mins
November 15, 2025
Listen
Translate
Change font size