Try GOLD - Free

Is it wrong to pin our hopes on hydrogen?

The Guardian Weekly

|

March 17, 2023

As funding grows and the fossil fuel industry promotes the fuel, concerns have arisen over its clean credentials

- Nina Lakhani

Is it wrong to pin our hopes on hydrogen?

Hydrogen is the smallest, lightest and most abundant molecule in the universe. On Earth, it does not occur by itself naturally, but can be separated from water (H2O) or hydrocarbon compounds (fossil fuels) such as gas, coal and petroleum to be used as an energy source. It’s already used for rocket fuel, but is now being pushed as a clean and safe alternative to oil and gas for heating and earthly transport. Political support is mounting with almost $26bn of US taxpayer money available for hydrogen projects . Hydrogen is politically hot, but is it the climate solution its cheerleaders claim?

Why all the hype about hydrogen?

 The fossil fuel industry sees hydrogen as a way to keep on drilling and building new infrastructure, and has successfully deployed its PR and lobbying machines to get policymakers thinking that hydrogen is a catch-all climate solution. Research by climate scientists (without fossil fuel links) has debunked industry claims that hydrogen should be a major player , though hydrogen extracted from water (using renewable energy sources) could – and should – play an important role in replacing the dirtiest hydrogen currently extracted from fossil fuels. It may also have a role in fuelling some transportation, such as long-haul flights and vintage cars, but the evidence is far from clear.

What’s the difference between blue, grey, brown, pink and green hydrogen?  

MORE STORIES FROM The Guardian Weekly

The Guardian Weekly

The Guardian Weekly

Feeling in a pickle? How leftover brine can give your cooking a kick

I’m an avid consumer of pickles. When I’ve finished a jar, how can I use the brine in my cooking?

time to read

2 mins

July 04, 2025

The Guardian Weekly

The Guardian Weekly

Cool retreats Hill stations swamped by tourists fleeing heat

Until recently, the drive up the mountainous road to Landour was a highlight of a visit to the hilltop town, as drivers enjoyed glorious Himalayan views and breathed in the cool forest air. Today, the journey is something to be endured with up to 1,000 cars a day clogging the narrow, winding road - slowing to navigate hairpin bends. A journey that once took five to six hours from Delhi can now take up to 10 hours, especially at weekends in May and June.

time to read

3 mins

July 04, 2025

The Guardian Weekly

The Guardian Weekly

How the rise of Zohran Mamdani has divided Democrats

The Friday night before election day, Zohran Mamdani, the 33-year-old democratic socialist running for mayor of New York City, walked the length of Manhattan, from Inwood Hill Park at its northern tip to the Battery - about 20km. Along the way, he was greeted by a stream of New Yorkers enjoying the sticky summer night - men rose from their folding chairs to shake his hand, drivers honked in support and diners leapt up to snap a selfie with the would-be leader of their city.

time to read

5 mins

July 04, 2025

The Guardian Weekly

‘It’s a fight for life’ Tipping points, doomerism and catastrophic risks

Climate expert Genevieve Guenther on the importance of correcting the false narrative that climate threat is under control... and why it is appropriate to be scared

time to read

5 mins

July 04, 2025

The Guardian Weekly

The Guardian Weekly

Call to revive the spirit of Greenham Common

In August 1981, 36 people, mainly women, walked from Wales to RAF Greenham Common in Berkshire to protest against the storing of US cruise missiles in the UK.

time to read

2 mins

July 04, 2025

The Guardian Weekly

The Guardian Weekly

Who are the jihadists waging a ghost war in the Sahel?

The scene is wearily familiar. It is dusk at a ramshackle military outpost, surrounded by miles of scrubby desert or on the outskirts of a major town.

time to read

3 mins

July 04, 2025

The Guardian Weekly

The Guardian Weekly

Will Ghibli's magic fade as the studio turns 40?

The beloved Japanese animation house faces an uncertain future, with its figurehead, 84-year-old Hayao Miyazaki, claiming he has made his final film

time to read

3 mins

July 04, 2025

The Guardian Weekly

The Guardian Weekly

The ripple effect

After America's blunt intervention, Donald Trump says the war between Iran and Israel is over. But the perceived readiness of the US to employ force instead of negotiations could have knock-on consequences around the world

time to read

4 mins

July 04, 2025

The Guardian Weekly

Broken justice...

Critics argue that far from shielding the world from the worst crimes, international law has protected states by helping them justify their wrongs. Is the system dying or merely in hibernation?

time to read

16 mins

July 04, 2025

The Guardian Weekly

While the death toll mounts, Israel's allies must help build a future for Palestinians

“We cannot be asking civilians to go into a combat zone so that then they can be killed with the justification that they are in a combat zone.” It defies belief that the Unicef spokesperson, James Elder, should have needed to spell that out last week.

time to read

2 mins

July 04, 2025

Translate

Share

-
+

Change font size