Try GOLD - Free
LEGAL MINEFIELD: LEASEHOLD, TENANCY RIGHTS AND THE CAPITAL GAINS TAX TRAP
Mint Kolkata
|May 29, 2025
You must value tenancy rights and leasehold at stamp duty rate for accurate tax calculations
The land was valued at Rs 1.25 crore for the purpose of stamp duty; he is required to pay capital gains tax based on a sale value of Rs 1.25 crore and not Rs 1 crore. The issue of whether Section 50C covers tenancy rights has been raised before various appellate authorities.
Judicial position on tenancy rights
In the case of Atul G. Puranik, a Mumbai tribunal rendered a decision in 2011, holding that Section 50C applied only to assets in the nature of 'land or building or both'. Leasehold rights are neither land nor building, so it was held that these provisions would not apply. This view was upheld in two other cases - CIT vs Heatex Products Pvt. Ltd, and CIT vs Greenfield Hotels and Estates Pvt. Ltd.
This story is from the May 29, 2025 edition of Mint Kolkata.
Subscribe to Magzter GOLD to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 10,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
MORE STORIES FROM Mint Kolkata
Mint Kolkata
Modulus taps UBS for private credit biz
Modulus Alternatives Investment Managers hired a veteran banker from UBS Group AG to lead its private credit business, according to people familiar with the matter, as demand for talent in the sector heats up.
1 min
January 07, 2026
Mint Kolkata
What the Union budget must do to get private capex going again
Long-term tax and regulatory certainty would grant private businesses the confidence to take risks
3 mins
January 07, 2026
Mint Kolkata
Ten top video games to look forward to in 2026
From the long-awaited GTA VI to fresh horror, superhero and sci-fi epics, 2026 is shaping up to be a blockbuster year
3 mins
January 07, 2026
Mint Kolkata
TVs ward off smartphone threat with AI
Uber robotaxis are on their way in, in 2026—and other AI news this week
1 min
January 07, 2026
Mint Kolkata
Average crude import cost falls below $60/barrel to 5-year low
India’s average crude oil import cost fell below $60 a barrel on Monday, the lowest in nearly five years, despite global geopolitical upheavals and sanctions against three major suppliers—Iran, Russia and Venezuela.
1 mins
January 07, 2026
Mint Kolkata
A study in deductions: How the taxman spots anomalies
A guide to how the tax system’s algorithms are flagging mismatches in Form 16, AIS and ITRs
4 mins
January 07, 2026
Mint Kolkata
Natco challenges Novo Nordisk’s Semaglutide patent
Hyderabad-based Natco Pharma Ltd has filed a patent revocation petition before the Delhi high court against Danish drugmaker Novo Nordisk, which sells weight-loss drug semaglutide under Wegovy brand name.
1 mins
January 07, 2026
Mint Kolkata
MAGINOT LINE FALLACY AND THE COSTLY ILLUSION OF TIMING THE MARKET CYCLES
In the years between World War I and World War II, France built what it believed was an impenetrable defensive barrier—the Maginot Line.
2 mins
January 07, 2026
Mint Kolkata
Mid-sized startups ditch unicorn chase to go public earlier
A growing cohort of mid-sized companies is considering a much earlier entry into public markets, unlike the post-pandemic boom of 2021 when Indian startups stayed private as long as possible in pursuit of unicorn valuations.
1 min
January 07, 2026
Mint Kolkata
Mandatory hallmarking for silver eyed
After making gold hallmarking mandatory, the government is now preparing to extend it to silver, beginning with a pilot project in select districts, a senior government official said on Tuesday.
2 mins
January 07, 2026
Listen
Translate
Change font size