Try GOLD - Free
Horror movie drops the ball
Mail & Guardian
|M&G 26 September 2025
HIM criticises the brutal sacrifices of the US's National Football League, but poor storytelling keeps it from becoming the genre hit it could've been
I had been looking forward to HIM for months. The first trailer intrigued me because I had never seen a horror film set in the world of American football. When I later found out Jordan Peele was involved, I was sold.
But here's my first complaint — the marketing was deceptive. The campaign leaned heavily into Peele's name, going so far as to create posters stacking his directorial hits (Get Out, Us, Nope) in neat vertical order before tacking on HIM at the bottom, as though it were his latest release. The problem? Peele didn't direct this film, he produced it.
That kind of positioning is a disservice to the actual director, Justin Tipping, who has to contend with audiences walking in expecting a Peele movie and walking out feeling duped before they have even given him a chance.
Fortunately, I knew about this before stepping into the cinema.
Unfortunately, what I discovered was a film that fumbled its promising concept with an incoherent, confusing story.
This story is from the M&G 26 September 2025 edition of Mail & Guardian.
Subscribe to Magzter GOLD to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 10,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
MORE STORIES FROM Mail & Guardian
Mail & Guardian
From opera to advocacy
Opera singer Pumeza Matshikiza on her commitment to disrupting the cycle of child abuse, music, education and advocacy — and being celebrated by Johannesburg's Hall of Fame
6 mins
M&G 24 October 2025
Mail & Guardian
A film of reckoning
A tender yet piercing reflection, the documentary 'Milisuthando' explores memory, love and the psychic scars left by South Africa's unhealed past
4 mins
M&G 24 October 2025
Mail & Guardian
ANC, IFP spat puts coalition at risk
Tension between the parties comes as Jacob Zuma's uMkhonto weSizwe submits a motion of no confidence in KZN premier Thamsanqa Ntuli
1 mins
M&G 24 October 2025
Mail & Guardian
Films trace the echoes of colonial history
Three powerful short films come together for a special screening at the Avalon Auditorium, Homecoming Centre, in Cape Town on Friday 31 October, exploring South Africa’s colonial past and the enduring legacy of slavery.
1 min
M&G 24 October 2025
Mail & Guardian
Mental health has no gender
In their books, Michelle Kekana and Marion Scher confront mental health issues through women's, queers' and men's stories
6 mins
M&G 24 October 2025
Mail & Guardian
Questions over transparency of
Long-term leases turn public land into corporate profit, but it's not clear how these deals are structured and whether communities are seeing their share
5 mins
M&G 24 October 2025
Mail & Guardian
Diwali across the world
Across continents, the Hindu festival unites families, faiths and nations in the shared belief that even the smallest flame can change the world
5 mins
M&G 24 October 2025
Mail & Guardian
ANC, DA ugly war over 'nonsense' BEE bill
The Democratic Alliance (DA) is facing a backlash over its plan to table a bill scrapping the country's broad-based black economic empowerment policy.
6 mins
M&G 24 October 2025
Mail & Guardian
'Make peace through dialogue'
Geraldine Fraser-Moleketi has spent much of her life where politics and principle meet. From her years in the anti-apartheid movement to her work in diplomacy and governance, she has carried one conviction: peace is built through dialogue, not decree.
4 mins
M&G 24 October 2025
Mail & Guardian
The sharp end of satire
The cartoonist behind This is Wild talks freedom, backlash and the strange joy of finding humour in political chaos
5 mins
M&G 24 October 2025
Listen
Translate
Change font size

