Try GOLD - Free
'I DIDN'T USE A CHAINSAW TO GET RID OF MIKE'S BODY...'
Irish Daily Star
|May 26, 2025
Ex-US soldier speaks out over Garda theory into slurry tank remains | Kelley working on farm with axe during hunt for missing farmer
THE suspect in the murder of farmer Michael Gaine says it is "preposterous" to suggest he used a chainsaw to dismember his remains.
This paper has now spoken at length to former US soldier Michael Kelley, 53, who last week admitted to us he was arrested by gardai on suspicion of the murder.
Mr Gaine's suspected dismembered remains were discovered in slurry which was spread on his farmland in Kenmare, Co Kerry.
Speaking to this paper in a lengthy phone interview just before gardai confirmed the remains had been formally identified, Mr Kelley told us he completely rejects the Garda theory that he used a chainsaw, found on the farm, to dismember his remains.
Once again insisting his innocence, Mr Kelley, who is now residing in Tralee, also told us he has no intention of fleeing - and he will "fight this one out no matter what."
"The chainsaw thing is preposterous or they would have charged me. I mean Texas Chainsaw Massacre bulls**t? I mean please. Preposterous," he said.
Mr Kelley, who is originally from Maine in the US, revealed to us that gardai showed him "glossy photographs" of the chainsaw seized from Mr Gaine's land and what he said to them when they did.
"They had colour glossy photos of the chainsaw. I said 'Where the f**k is the glossy photograph of anything having to do with Michael Gaine's body?' I didn't see it," he said.
"This is a little card game that they're playing. Where's your evidence? Where's the macabre photo?
"They don't have it. They have nothing and if they did show me a colour glossy photo of the human remains they had I bet you I would have called bulls**t right there and said there's no way that those human remains could be his."

This story is from the May 26, 2025 edition of Irish Daily Star.
Subscribe to Magzter GOLD to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 10,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
MORE STORIES FROM Irish Daily Star
Irish Daily Star
MART'S AT THE RACES
O'Neill has experienced joy and despair chasing league titles and says of latest bid: It's not impossible but an uphill task
3 mins
January 24, 2026
Irish Daily Star
Brilliant Rachel takes the Duff road to victory
Irish player & fellow Traitor Stephen clear out the Faithfuls to bag €55K
1 mins
January 24, 2026
Irish Daily Star
A WHOLE NEW BALL GAME
Storylines everywhere - but Kerry and Cork dominate the 2026 focus
4 mins
January 24, 2026
Irish Daily Star
REED'S WELL ON THE WAY TO A FINE START
PATRICK REED is on course to pay off his $tmillion in fines for playing on LIV Golf this season after taking the halfway lead at the Hero Dubai Desert Classic.
2 mins
January 24, 2026
Irish Daily Star
WHAM! BAM! SEE YA, CAM
Norrie crashes out on another bad day for British
2 mins
January 24, 2026
Irish Daily Star
VLAD LAND DEMANDS
Donbas focus in Abu Dhabi peace talks
2 mins
January 24, 2026
Irish Daily Star
Coco happy to survive friendly Hail storm
COCO GAUFF came from a set down to beat good friend Hailey Baptiste 3-6 6-0 6-3.
1 min
January 24, 2026
Irish Daily Star
Bruna will be remembered with dignity, truth & love
THE family of a woman strangled by her obsessed ex-boyfriend cheered as he was jailed for life yesterday and said: \"She will always be remembered.\"
4 mins
January 24, 2026
Irish Daily Star
I WON'T LOSE MY ED IN MARKET MADNESS
Howe refuses to panic buy as Toon are hampered by PSR
2 mins
January 24, 2026
Irish Daily Star
Europe needs to learn mob schtick Don's offers can be refused
AS DONALD Trump ramps up his Goodfellas schtick, a wise-guy who regards the entire planet as his own Little Italy to menace and extort, the world must confront a truth as self-evident as the snow blanketing Greenland.
6 mins
January 24, 2026
Listen
Translate
Change font size

