Try GOLD - Free

Is Mulder's decision to let legends lie an admirable act of sportsmanship or folly?

Daily Maverick

|

July 11, 2025

Wiaan Mulder's decision to declare with his own score on 367 not out in the second Test against Zimbabwe seemed to be a selfless act. But was it wise?

- By Craig Ray

Wiaan Mulder's decision to deprive himself of the chance of holding the batting record for the highest individual score in Test cricket appears to be one of the greatest acts of sportsmanship of all time.

Mulder forfeited his chance of making history when he declared with his score on 367, out of respect for Brian Lara. "I thought we had had enough and we needed to bowl," Mulder said after the match.

"Secondly, Brian Lara is a legend. He got 401, or whatever it was [400], against England. For someone of that stature to keep that record is pretty special.

"If I get the chance again, I would probably do the same thing. Speaking to Shuks [coach Shukri Conrad], he said to me: 'Listen, let the legends keep the really big scores.'

"You never know what my fate is or what's destined for me, but I think Brian Lara keeping that record is exactly the way it should be."

A part of me loves this because, apart from my personal belief that Lara is the greatest batter I have ever seen, it shows that Mulder has a sense of history about the game. But there is also some disappointment for Mulder. Did he really think he was not worthy to take the record by stepping back to leave it for the "legends"? He might still go on to be a legend, yet is unlikely to get the chance to come so close to 400 again.

There has been much debate about the decision, and many comments on a wide array of traditional and social media platforms have suggested that Zimbabwe are so weak that there would always be an asterisk next to Mulder's name had he broken the record. I understand the sentiment, but when Lara set his record of 400 not out in Antigua against England in 2004, he was batting on a flat, lifeless pitch that gave little to no assistance to the bowlers.

MORE STORIES FROM Daily Maverick

Daily Maverick

Huge loss of wild mammals weighs heavily on Earth

New study reveals how the biomass of marine and terrestrial mammals has plunged since 1850

time to read

4 mins

November 14, 2025

Daily Maverick

What's in a name? As it turns out, significant meaning and power

What am I but my name? I’m fairly sure the first time I heard the phrase was in a radio conversation with Trevor Manuel when he explained why he felt it was important to sue the EFF for defamation (he won).

time to read

2 mins

November 14, 2025

Daily Maverick

Inflation target lowered to 3%

In a widely expected move, the finance minister announced the new target, which he said would benefit households, businesses and the government. Investors will no doubt be pleased, too.

time to read

3 mins

November 14, 2025

Daily Maverick

This kasi crime cartel movie asks you to suspend your disbelief

The strange narrative of how the 'Big Five' cartel has managed to infiltrate the SAPS is in danger of becoming a disappointing straight-to-video release

time to read

5 mins

November 14, 2025

Daily Maverick

Daily Maverick

Aarto postponed yet again as municipalities are unprepared

The new law that will introduce a points demerit system for traffic violations will not become operational as planned. This time the postponement is due to municipal law enforcement not being ready.

time to read

2 mins

November 14, 2025

Daily Maverick

Relief for family as British soldier

The former medic accused of killing Agnes Wanjiru has been arrested and is facing extradition. After 13 long years, her family's constant pressure has finally pushed the wheels of justice into motion. By Ufrieda Ho

time to read

4 mins

November 14, 2025

Daily Maverick

Turning Esterhuizen into a hybrid player has paid off handsomely

Having a player such as André Esterhuizen who can operate at flank and centre was crucial for the Springboks during their 32-17 win over France. By Craig Ray

time to read

4 mins

November 14, 2025

Daily Maverick

New study shows that being creative can help keep the brain younger

Creative experiences such as dancing, painting and gaming were linked to younger-looking brains, researchers found. By Carlos Coronel and Agustín Ibáñez

time to read

4 mins

November 14, 2025

Daily Maverick

Investment options for you that generate steady after-tax income

I am a 74-year-old widow and recently sold a property for R4-million. How should I invest the proceeds to generate the best after-tax income?

time to read

3 mins

November 14, 2025

Daily Maverick

Daily Maverick

Nandi Dlepu's limitless creativity

Meet a cultural curator who is reimagining Johannesburg's creative landscape. By Bridget Hilton-Barber

time to read

2 mins

November 14, 2025

Listen

Translate

Share

-
+

Change font size