Go Unlimited with Magzter GOLD
Get unlimited access to 10,000+ magazines, newspapers and Premium stories for just
Try GOLD - Free
Smith considers legal action after ruling on unconstitutional search
Cape Argus
|September 15, 2025
MAYCO member for Safety and Security, JP Smith, often dubbed “the Sheriff” of the City, said he’s receiving legal advice whether to pursue steps for retribution following the Western Cape High Court’s decision declaring the search at his municipal offices as unconstitutional.
The ruling follows litigation brought by Smith and Limberg after a SAPS Commercial Crimes Unit raid on their offices on January 24.
Hours after Smith released the court’s findings, the Cape Argus asked Smith whether he would be seeking compensation financially for defamation of character, to which he answered: “I'm taking advice from my legal team, I am usually not a person that seeks retribution but I am aware that if you do not keep those accountable who misuse the criminal justice system, they will continue to weaponise it against their opponents.”
Smith’s colleague, Xanthea Limberg, mayco member for Energy, who was the second applicant in their court application, which respondents included Mayor Geordin Hill-Lewis, Provincial Police Commissioner, Thembisile Patekile, Carel Johannes Lourens, the Minister of Police and many others.
This story is from the September 15, 2025 edition of Cape Argus.
Subscribe to Magzter GOLD to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 10,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
MORE STORIES FROM Cape Argus
Cape Argus
Letlapa's birthday rocket sends Sekhukhune United into quarter-finals
SEKHUKHUNE
2 mins
February 23, 2026
Cape Argus
Thousands march in France for slain far-right activist
THOUSANDS of people marched in southeastern France at the weekend under heavy security in tribute to a far-right activist whose killing, blamed on the hard left, has put the country on edge.
2 mins
February 23, 2026
Cape Argus
AUCTIONING ANCESTRAL LAND 'A SLAP IN THE FACE'
Indigenous groups move to block sale
3 mins
February 23, 2026
Cape Argus
Rare 10-day break could give Chiefs the edge
TWO weeks ago, Kaizer Chiefs looked like a club in freefall.
2 mins
February 23, 2026
Cape Argus
Luus and Jafta shine as Proteas Women secure victory
THE Proteas Women beat Pakistan by 37 runs in the rain-affected first One Day International of the three-match series at Mangaung Oval in Bloemfontein yesterday.
2 mins
February 23, 2026
Cape Argus
Proteas silence Ahmedabad
WHEN the Narendra Modi Stadium was commissioned, it was meant to be the coliseum to celebrate all India's pending modern-day cricket achievements.
3 mins
February 23, 2026
Cape Argus
West Indies prepare to face X-factor Chevron
WEST Indies coach Daren Sammy said yesterday his side had plans to counter Zimbabwe' giant quick bowler Blessing Muzarabani, while admitting the 2.03m beanpole had the “X-factor”.
2 mins
February 23, 2026
Cape Argus
E-hailing drivers call for action after attack
AN E-HAILING driver is fighting for his life after he was shot in the face and hijacked by four gunmen in Rylands, Athlone.
1 mins
February 23, 2026
Cape Argus
Vuyani Pambo and Jackie Phamotse unite for new book
SOUTH African politician and former student activist Vuyani Pambo is entering a new chapter through his collaboration with author Jackie Phamotse.
3 mins
February 23, 2026
Cape Argus
Net closes on alleged human trafficking as two arrested
IN A BREAKTHROUGH, the Western Cape Economic Protected Resources team arrested two human trafficking suspects who are allegedly linked to a case involving the exploitation of four victims who were misled with promises of legitimate employment opportunities in Thailand.
1 mins
February 23, 2026
Listen
Translate
Change font size