Try GOLD - Free
England must get best out of Smith
The Rugby Paper
|October 15, 2023
STEVE Borthwick does not have a lot of choice when it comes to selecting his forwards for today's quarter-final against Fiji because the options are limited, but the plusses are that Ollie Chessum looks like he's coming back to his best, and Ben Earl has been getting good raps.
-
However, although there have been signs of more consistency in the pool stage - and Chessum's try against Samoa, and others, have been reasonably well worked-overall England have not been playing well. The main reason for this is a high error count, and particularly the amount of compound errors, where one mistake follows another. These are like a hammer blow for any team.
England will have to resolve this against Fiji, and they will also have to work out how to get the best from Marcus Smith, because I did not see head coach Borthwick picking him out of position at full-back in a World Cup quarter-final.
In one sense it can be seen as a positive, because Borthwick has been pretty conservative in selection, but it is also a risk. Fiji do kick, especially box-kicks from scrumhalf, and they are much better drilled than they were, including no longer playing fifteens like sevens.
Smith is in a difficult position because the expectation is for him to carry England to glory in Marseille with his footwork, pace, and playmaking skill-set. The difference between Owen Farrell and Smith at fly-half is that Farrell plays by rote, whereas Smith reacts to what is in front of him - but expecting him to do it from full-back is a big ask.
Borthwick's decision to go with Farrell over Ford is also no surprise, because Farrell is his choice as captain, and against Fiji's big runners is probably more effective at 10 in the front-on defence required against them.
I don't believe that the Fijian kicking will be loose from scrumhalf, and it could expose England to high ball pressure across the whole of the back three without Freddie Steward in the starting 15, with Smith replacing him, and Jonny May and Elliot Daly on the wings.
This story is from the October 15, 2023 edition of The Rugby Paper.
Subscribe to Magzter GOLD to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 10,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
MORE STORIES FROM The Rugby Paper
The Rugby Paper
Spain push Argentina all the way
ARGENTINA clinched a thrilling victory over Spain with a dramatic second half comeback.
1 mins
July 06, 2025
The Rugby Paper
When Alfie is always the star man
ALLAN Langer, the Queensland rugby league legend, is honoured with a statue outside Suncorp Stadium, in Brisbane, the venue for Wednesday's Lions game with the Reds.
1 min
July 06, 2025
The Rugby Paper
Ireland miss chance to get past Italians
IRELAND'S bid to reach the semifinals suffered a damaging setback as they slipped to a heartbreaking defeat against hosts Italy in Viadana.
1 mins
July 06, 2025
The Rugby Paper
O'Brien is quick to take charge for Ireland
IRELAND secured a confident and controlled victory in Tbilisi, propelled by a try-double from debutant wing Tommy O'Brien and one from first-time captain Craig Casey.
1 mins
July 06, 2025
The Rugby Paper
Wingers to the fore for England
ENGLAND began their U20s World Championship title defence with a commanding 56-19 victory over Scotland in Verona.
2 mins
July 06, 2025
The Rugby Paper
Gibson-Park and Russell happy as they fall into step
JAMISON Gibson-Park passed his Lions Test match audition with dance partner Finn Russell and admitted the pair had hardly rehearsed.
1 mins
July 06, 2025
The Rugby Paper
Woeful Wales are humiliated one more time
WALES' embarrassment knows no bounds as they surrendered a 19-7 lead to chalk up their 18th consecutive defeat, easily a record for a Tier 1 nation in the professional era.
2 mins
July 06, 2025
The Rugby Paper
Bordeaux & Saints are set for Cup rematch
EUROPEAN champions Bordeaux-Begles and last season’s finalists Northampton have been drawn in Pool 4 for the 2025-26 Champions Cup.
1 mins
July 06, 2025
The Rugby Paper
Farrell's call-up shouldn't cause discord
THE furore surrounding Owen Farrell being brought into the Lions squad as a replacement for Elliott Daly has stirred the nepotism bad genie.
1 mins
July 06, 2025
The Rugby Paper
Scotland hold on to deny brave Māori
SCOTLAND claimed a first-ever win over the Māori All Blacks with a thrilling victory in Whangõrei to kick off their Pacific tour in style.
1 min
July 06, 2025
Translate
Change font size

