Try GOLD - Free
IS IAN STILL IN THERE?
The Atlantic
|June 2025
People in a vegetative state may be far more conscious than was once thought.

Inside the truck, the bodies of three teenage boys hurled forward, each with terrible velocity.
One boy died instantly; a second was found alive outside the car. The third boy, Ian Berg, remained pinned in the driver's seat, a bruise blooming on the right side of his forehead. He had smacked it hard-much harder than one might have guessed from the bruise alone-which caused the soft mass of his brain to slam against the rigid confines of his skull. Where brain met bone, brain gave way. The matter of his mind stretched and twisted, tore and burst.
When the jaws of life freed him from the wreckage, Ian was still alive, but unconscious. "Please don't die. Please don't die.
Please don't die," his mother, Eve Baer, pleaded over him at the hospital. She imagined throwing a golden lasso around his foot to keep him from floating away.
And Ian didn't die. After 17 days in a coma, he finally opened his eyes, but they flicked wildly around the room, unable to sync or track. He could not speak. He could not control his limbs.
The severe brain injury he'd suffered, doctors said, had put him in a vegetative state. He was alive, but assumed to be cognitively gone-devoid of thought, of feeling, of consciousness.
Eve hated that term, vegetative-an "unhuman-type classification," she thought. If you had asked her then, in 1986, she would have said she expected her 17-year-old son to fully recover. Ian had been handsome, popular, in love with a new girlfriend-the kind of golden boy upon whom fortune smiles. At school, he was known as the kid who greeted everyone, teachers included, with a hug. He and his two friends in the car belonged to a tight-knit group of seniors. But on the day he would have graduated that June, Ian was still lying in a hospital bed, his big achievement being that he'd finally made a bowel movement.
This story is from the June 2025 edition of The Atlantic.
Subscribe to Magzter GOLD to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,500+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
MORE STORIES FROM The Atlantic

The Atlantic
CANADA IS KILLING ITSELF
THE COUNTRY GAVE ITS CITIZENS THE RIGHT TO DIE...DOCTORS ARE STRUGGLING TO KEEP UP WITH DEMAND.
28 mins
September 2025

The Atlantic
WHY MARRIAGE SURVIVES
The institution has adapted, and is showing new signs of resilience.
9 mins
September 2025

The Atlantic
The Forgotten Still-Life Prodigy
The 17th-century painter Rachel Ruysch was once more famous than Vermeer.
9 mins
September 2025

The Atlantic
THIS IS WHAT THE END OF THE LIBERAL WORLD ORDER LOOKS LIKE
In a post-American world, greed and nihilism are destroying Sudan.
39 mins
September 2025

The Atlantic
The Judgments of Muriel Spark
The novelist Muriel Spark died almost 20 years ago, but she still regularly appears on lists of top comic novelists to read on this subject or that. Crave more White Lotus-level skewering of the ridiculous rich? Try Memento Mori, The New York Times suggests. An acerbic take on boring dinner parties? Symposium. Interested in “the fun and funny aspects of being a teacher”? Read The Prime of Miss Jean Brodie— also good for learning how to be a highly inappropriate teacher, if you want to know that too.
12 mins
September 2025

The Atlantic
Playing Mailman
A new memoir considers what public service is, and what it isn't.
8 mins
September 2025

The Atlantic
Chasing le Carré in Corfu
If you're trying to find someone who doesn't want to be found, you don't go to the obvious places.
20 mins
September 2025

The Atlantic
THE MAN WHO ATE NASA
The agency once projected America's loftiest ideals. Then it ceded its ambitions to Elon Musk.
27 mins
September 2025

The Atlantic
CAPTAIN RON'S GUIDE TO FEARLESS FLYING
The pilot who calms the nerves of anxious fliers
7 mins
September 2025

The Atlantic
GOING BACK
What home meant before, and after, Hurricane Katrina
10 mins
September 2025
Listen
Translate
Change font size