Dynasties: Tanya Gold Fall of the House of Windsor The crisis behind the tabloid sensation surrounding Princess Catherine.
New York magazine
|March 11-24, 2024
TO OUTSIDERS, the British royal family can seem like a curio.
-
They are gaudy waxworks who promote tourism and evoke the time when this country ruled a fifth of the globe. They signify the myth of British exceptionalism and embody a sensibility more rooted in the Blitz than the 21st century: patience, good manners, and repression (spun into health as a stiff upper lip). They are a strand of our national culture, like Miss Marple, Sherlock Holmes, and Earl Grey tea. They are remote and inhuman: near-fictional beings.
But the reality is crueler and more serious. That we in Britain obsess over the Windsors-rather than, say, the cost-of-living crisis, the wreckage of Brexit, or galloping child poverty-is typical of our semi-functioning politics. Like all fairy tales and fables, monarchy infantilizes us, and like a drug, it eats into real life, starting with the lives of the royals themselves. Princess Diana was a fairy-tale princess until she ended up dead. Now, with a swiftness that no one could have expected after the death of Elizabeth II in 2022, the monarchy is potentially fracturing.
Unreliable leadership has become a commonplace in Britain-four prime ministers gone since 2016, and a fifth, Rishi Sunak, likely on his way out later this year-but the royal family is for the first time in living memory also proving unstable. Prince Andrew, the king's brother, was exiled from Buckingham Palace for sexual predation. Prince Harry exiled himself with testimony about racism toward his wife, Meghan. Now, 18 months into his reign, King Charles III is sick with an unnamed cancer and has all but withdrawn from public life. Catherine, the Princess of Wales (née Kate Middleton), is also sick, sparking a transatlantic tabloid frenzy that has put intense scrutiny on her marriage to Charles's successor, Prince William, of a kind reminiscent of the trauma that cracked the marriage of Charles and Diana. The lurid headlines suggest the matter is frivolous; rather, they mask a crisis.
This story is from the March 11-24, 2024 edition of New York magazine.
Subscribe to Magzter GOLD to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 10,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
MORE STORIES FROM New York magazine
New York magazine
Will You Come and Get Me?'
The provocative festival hit The Voice of Hind Rajab reenacts the 5-year-old girl's call to emergency dispatchers in Gaza just before she was killed.
12 mins
December 15-28, 2025
New York magazine
The Eyes Wide Shut Conspiracy
Did Stanley Kubrick warn us about Jeffrey Epstein?
13 mins
December 15-28, 2025
New York magazine
He Just Got It
Robert A.M. Stern embraced New York as a collective project.
5 mins
December 15-28, 2025
New York magazine
REASONS TO LOVE NEW YORK (RIGHT NOW)
OUR 21ST ANNUAL REMINDER OF WHY WE WOULDN'T WANT TO LIVE ANYWHERE ELSE. RENT HIKES, RAT KINGS, AND ALL
7 mins
December 15-28, 2025
New York magazine
The Revenants
Marjorie Prime is a thoughtful, well-wrought play that's cool to the touch
4 mins
December 15-28, 2025
New York magazine
Solo Act
In Pluribus, Rhea Seehorn plays the loneliest woman in the world, a role that creator Vince Gilligan wrote just for her.
7 mins
December 15-28, 2025
New York magazine
The War on Everything Doctrine
Hegseth's deadly missile strikes mirror Trump's domestic priorities.
5 mins
December 15-28, 2025
New York magazine
Kumail Nanjiani Strikes Back
The stand-up manages to come across as relatable—even after years in Hollywood
5 mins
December 15-28, 2025
New York magazine
Where the Wild Chairs Are
A designer’s unconventional furniture upends his traditional prewar apartment.
2 mins
December 15-28, 2025
New York magazine
What We Give Our Children
THERE ARE INFINITE WAYS to delight a child with a gift-and as many ways to miss the mark. Seven Strategist staffers with kids of their own discussed the best presents for all types of little ones, from newborns to hard-to-please tweens, that won't end up in the regift pile.
3 mins
December 15-28, 2025
Listen
Translate
Change font size

