Try GOLD - Free
HEAD TO HEAD SUPER SALOONS
BBC Top Gear UK
|September 2024
This should just be your usual, regular, ultra fast, four door battle. But after what AMG has done to one of our very favourite speed machines, it's anything but. It's AMG C63 vs Alfa QF...

We had our first go in the new MercedesAMG C63 in December 2022. It's taken until midsummer '24 to meet it again, and the resulting information vacuum has been gleefully filled by the internet, awash with rumours that Mercedes is panicking. That not a single person in Germany has strolled into a Merc dealership and asked to buy the new 2.0-litre hybrid C63. The Chinese market cannot reconcile how the 4cyl C63 is superior to the cheaper 6cyl C43. Someone confidently asserted it's being quietly euthanised, while engineers desperately lube thump great V8s with Lurpak and attempt to shoehorn them beneath the C63's twin domed bonnet.
We're assured none of these things are true. The internet is officially wrong, nothing to see here. Apparently the C63 just needed some software updates, which were downloaded via dial-up. But would you be surprised to see the svelte CLE coupe (basically a two-door C-Class) offered with a V8 to appease the faithful before long? I wouldn't.
This is 2023's sorry, I mean 2024's most controversial car. It was always going to be tough to replace the old C63 - TG regulars should leaf back to 2017's issue 300, when the V8 coupe nuked the new Audi RS5, Lexus RCF and BMW's mighty M4. We called it "one of the very best cars on sale today". Replacing it with an engine half the size, inspired by one of the most lambasted hypercar launches in history? Baby and bathwater, binned.
This story is from the September 2024 edition of BBC Top Gear UK.
Subscribe to Magzter GOLD to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 10,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
MORE STORIES FROM BBC Top Gear UK

BBC Top Gear UK
CLEAN SLATE
Minimalism is back... and so is a proper sports car in Audi's line up. Meet the Concept C, yours in two years' time
5 mins
November 2025

BBC Top Gear UK
AMG ONE VS THE REAL WORLD
Yep, we drove the AMG on the road too... and lived to tell the tale
8 mins
November 2025

BBC Top Gear UK
THE ART OF ILLUSION
Fancy an iconic classic but short a few million? There's a garage in Japan that could well be the answer to your dreams
4 mins
November 2025

BBC Top Gear UK
SHOW BIZ
The motor show is dead, apparently... nobody told Munich. But what's a day pounding the carpets really like in 2025? We dispatched Sam to soak it all in
8 mins
November 2025

BBC Top Gear UK
HYBRID CROSSOVERS
The Qashqai was the original crossover... these days it's been leapfrogged in the pecking order. Can a Dacia beat the OG?
5 mins
November 2025

BBC Top Gear UK
DACIA BIGSTER
£24,995 OTR/£26,700 as tested/£114 pcm WHY IT'S HERE: Value motoring for a decently sized SUV. But is the Bigster bigster value or just cheap?
1 mins
November 2025

BBC Top Gear UK
FURY ROAD
Meet the Hennessey Venom F5 Revolution Evo... the world's most powerful internal combustion road car.
9 mins
November 2025

BBC Top Gear UK
let's freaking go!
Never has being physically assaulted from multiple angles felt like such fun.
5 mins
November 2025

BBC Top Gear UK
IN THE SHADOW OF GIANTS
The S1 LM is a tribute to arguably the world's greatest racing car, based on the world's best supercar. Here's how it happened, from the man who dreamed it up...
8 mins
November 2025

BBC Top Gear UK
Shape shifters
More and more companies are embracing the idea that a watch can be whatever shape it wants
2 mins
November 2025
Listen
Translate
Change font size