Try GOLD - Free
AMG ONE VS THE REAL WORLD
BBC Top Gear UK
|November 2025
Yep, we drove the AMG on the road too... and lived to tell the tale
The messaging from the AMG then, is mixed. If you know the technical backstory, what happens next won't come as such a surprise, but if your experience has only been visual, taking in the sleek bodywork and awkward but manageable access, start up is going to come as quite the shock.
Not for the fact that from cold you have to wait 50-60 seconds for the cats to preheat, but that once they have I've never come across a car that sounds quite as broken at idle. It honestly made me think the crankshaft had snapped and was busily churning the engine internals to pieces. It's awful. It turns out Lewis Hamilton won F1 championships with something that brought the sounds of a construction site to the pitlane.
We're at Thruxton. It's everything a Tilke track isn't. Gritty, intimidating and puckeringly fast with zero friendly runoff.
We've come here because it's the UK's fastest circuit and we want to feel the downforce. An F1 car has been here but only once.
In 1993 Damon Hill used his Williams FW15C to set an all time lap record of 57.6secs at an average speed of 147mph. Dearie me.
Honestly, if you haven't been, come here, do one of the track experiences and while you're bricking yourself through the endless right after Noble, ponder that lap time.
It's pouring with rain and both are wearing barely there track tyres... since neither Jethro or I fancy a trip across Thruxton's endless grass we amuse ourselves by weighing the cars. Full of fuel the Valkyrie comes in at 1,340kg, the One at 1,745kg. Now 405kg more is a lot. But let's put this in context. The Valkyrie is a simple car - rear drive, V12 dominant and as stripped bare as a prison cell. It is a wheeled self-flagellation chamber (only there's no room to swing the whip). Yes, the AMG has a smaller engine, but then there are the additions, most notably a pair of front electric motors and a much bigger battery pack (8.4kWh versus 1.3).
This story is from the November 2025 edition of BBC Top Gear UK.
Subscribe to Magzter GOLD to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 10,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
MORE STORIES FROM BBC Top Gear UK
BBC Top Gear UK
GARAGE
BENTLEY CONTI GT · DACIA BIGSTER · JEEP WRANGLER · JAECOO 7 · MINI COUNTRYMAN · VOLVO EX30 · RICCI'S GARAGE · PORSCHE MACAN · VOLKSWAGEN ID.BUZZ · TOYOTA LAND CRUISER
5 mins
January 2026
BBC Top Gear UK
IT'S BEEN A BAD YEAR
“To lose one... may be regarded as a misfortune.
2 mins
January 2026
BBC Top Gear UK
THE OVERRUN
Small but perfectly formed reviews. The best of this month's drives
6 mins
January 2026
BBC Top Gear UK
KIMERA EVO37
PERFORMANCE CAR OF THE YEAR
2 mins
January 2026
BBC Top Gear UK
What exactly is the future of the car, wonders Jethro
It must have gone on for 30 minutes. A heated debate choosing the winner of PCOTY in a cafe in Malhada Quente. The truth is, we all knew the outcome.
2 mins
January 2026
BBC Top Gear UK
FERRARI F80
Chronic hypercar fatigue has been officially recognised by the UK Health Security Agency for the first time in 2025.
2 mins
January 2026
BBC Top Gear UK
YANGWANG U9
Times are a-changing, a Chinese EV is now the fastest car in the world
1 mins
January 2026
BBC Top Gear UK
IT'S BEEN A GOOD YEAR
September is the big sales month in Britain.
2 mins
January 2026
BBC Top Gear UK
6 REASONS RENAULTS FLYING
One car company above all others has had the most ridiculous slam dunk of a year.
11 mins
January 2026
BBC Top Gear UK
MIKE'S CHANNEL
ARE BORING CARS THE NEW INTERESTING CARS?
2 mins
January 2026
Listen
Translate
Change font size
