Try GOLD - Free
‘I WAS SWITCHED AT BIRTH'
Woman's Day Australia
|February 24 2020
Two families were torn apart when their newborn babies were switched in hospital 42 years ago
-
The woman at the centre of an infamous switched-atbirth scandal has spoken out about how the terrible unsolved crime effectively robbed her of two sets of parents and continues to haunt her to this day.
A deathbed confession on top of a multimillion-dollar settlement didn’t bring closure to the families of Kimberly Mays and Arlena Twigg, who were born three days apart at the Hardee Memorial Hospital in rural Wauchula, Florida in 1978.
“It’s been anything but easy,” revealed Kimberly in an interview with US show 20/20, explaining she ultimately became estranged from both sets of parents after the shock discovery came to light in 1988.
This nightmare for the Mays and the Twiggs started after an unidentified person unclipped the name tags wrapped around Kimberly and Arlena’s tiny wrists and swapped them, leaving two mothers to nurse, love and take home a stranger’s child.
Regina and Ernest Twigg’s healthy baby was given to Bob and Barbara Mays, while the Mays’ daughter, who was born with a severe heart condition, was given to the Twiggs – with the mix-up not discovered until Arlena died nine years later.

SINISTER CRIME?
This story is from the February 24 2020 edition of Woman's Day Australia.
Subscribe to Magzter GOLD to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 10,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
MORE STORIES FROM Woman's Day Australia
Woman's Day Australia
SMALL WONDERS
Even the tiniest space can become an outdoor oasis
3 mins
January 5, 2026
Woman's Day Australia
WORLD'S MOST BRAZEN HEISTS
From jewels to cash and art, nothing was off limits for these master thieves
3 mins
January 5, 2026
Woman's Day Australia
17-YEAR SILENCE OVER!
It's the first time Guy Ritchie and Madonna have been in the same room since their bitter divorce in 2008.
1 min
January 5, 2026
Woman's Day Australia
SALAD SEASON
Delightful flavour-packed mains in half an hour
2 mins
January 5, 2026
Woman's Day Australia
HELP AT HAND
Asking for help is the all-important first step
2 mins
January 5, 2026
Woman's Day Australia
CHILLING KILLER CONFESSIONS
The true nature of their crimes were laid bare when they explained their actions
3 mins
January 5, 2026
Woman's Day Australia
GEORGE MOURNS SISTER 'SHE WAS SO BRAVE'
George Clooney is mourning the loss of his older sister Adelia \"Ada❞ Zeidler, who tragically passed away from cancer aged 65.
1 min
January 5, 2026
Woman's Day Australia
SALLY FAULKNER'S JOY REUNITED WITH HER CHILDREN
After a botched 60 Minutes retrieval, the family are together at last
3 mins
January 5, 2026
Woman's Day Australia
THE BLOCK'S SARAH REVEALS POSTNATAL DEPRESSION
When Sarah and George Bragias appeared on The Block in 2020, they were child-free, active and appeared to be healthy.
1 min
January 5, 2026
Woman's Day Australia
'SURPRISE!' EMILY DEBUTS NEW MAN
After her fairytale engagement to Married At First Sight's Ryan Gallagher abruptly ended, Olympic swimming great Emily Seebohm has announced she has a new man!
1 min
January 5, 2026
Translate
Change font size
