Try GOLD - Free

Sweating The Details

Motor Trend

|

June 2018

THE SMALL STUFF MATTERS FOR THESE TWO $40K LUXURY CROSSOVERS

- Christian Seabaugh

Sweating The Details

Details matter, especially when it comes to luxury. When you can get leather in a Ford Fiesta, those hoping to compete in the luxury space need to sweat the small stuff to succeed. Volvo and VW both have gotten the message.

Long viewed in this country as alternatives for luxury and mainstream buyers avoiding a “traditional” choice, both brands have been making major efforts toward increasing market shares. For Volkswagen, this has meant more premium trim levels and a new compact crossover promising German design and performance at a value price. For Volvo, it’s new CUVs that stand for the ideals of Scandinavian luxury.

The 2018 Volkswagen Tiguan SEL TSI 4Motion and the 2018 Volvo XC60 T5 AWD represent this shift, and although one was designed to steal sales from Toyota and the other from Audi, there’s enough overlap that we decided it was a good idea to invite them to compete as part of our $40,000 “Is Luxury Worth It?” challenge.

For buyers looking for a more luxurious mainstream compact crossover, the new Tiguan is a pretty compelling option. VW has previously crossed the line between mainstream and luxury brands (anyone remember the Phaeton or W-8-powered Passat?), and with the top trim Tiguan SEL, VW looks like it’s found the sweet spot. The Tiguan has attractive new sheetmetal and a lengthy list of standard features, including an Audi-esque digital instrument cluster and driver-assist features. It has the luxury front covered, too, with a heated steering wheel, heated seats, a Fender audio system, and a full-length panoramic sunroof. Our attractive white-on-black-on-orange Tiguan SEL tester stickers for $38,950, its only options being the $5,160 Premium package and the $500 third-row seat.

MORE STORIES FROM Motor Trend

Motor Trend

Motor Trend

Porsche Panamera 4S E-Hybrid

PROS Excellent hybrid powertrain Delightful handling Isolated interior CONS Emotionally distant Obnoxious tech Ever-larger starting price

time to read

2 mins

Winter 2026

Motor Trend

Motor Trend

Porsche Taycan Cross Turismo

PROS 300-plus miles of real-world range Quickest-charging vehicle we've tested Still drives like a Porsche CONS Still priced like a Porsche Slightly less efficient than the Taycan sedan Slightly less fun, too

time to read

2 mins

Winter 2026

Motor Trend

Motor Trend

Audi S3/RS 3

Audi's compact luxury sport sedans were updated for the 2025 model year, giving them more power, new signature lighting, and other styling upgrades. They continue to ride on the same MQB platform that dates back to 2015. Are the upgrades enough to keep them in the fight?

time to read

2 mins

Winter 2026

Motor Trend

Motor Trend

GMC Sierra EV

PROS Big range Good towing manners Super Cruise delights CONS Still pricey with options Useless off-road Frivolous features

time to read

2 mins

Winter 2026

Motor Trend

Motor Trend

THE CADILLAC ESCALADE IQ IS THE STANDARD OF THE WORLD, AGAIN

This story, in a way, begins with the Lincoln Navigator.

time to read

5 mins

Winter 2026

Motor Trend

Motor Trend

Audi A5/S5

The smaller end of Audi's lineup is undergoing what's known in corporate parlance as a restructuring, shrinking from the A4 sedan, A5 coupe and convertible, and A5 Sportback (plus each one's sportier S version) to just one model: the A5 and the more powerful S5.

time to read

2 mins

Winter 2026

Motor Trend

Motor Trend

Audi A6/S6 E-Tron

As is seemingly the case with every traditional mainstream automaker these days, Audi has struggled to find the right balance between the gas and electric vehicles in its lineup. Charging into this conundrum are the A6 E-Tron and S6 E-Tron.

time to read

2 mins

Winter 2026

Motor Trend

Motor Trend

FORD'S EXCELLENT SMALL PICKUP EARNS OUR HIGHEST HONOR AT LAST

Are pickups becoming caricatures of their former selves? They seem to grow larger and heavier with each successive redesign to the point where you need staircase tailgates just to load them. Swimming against this tsunami is the wee Ford Maverick, a pickup that allows normal-sized human adults to reach in over the side rail and grab items off the bed floor without even standing on tippy-toes. The climb into the bed is manageable without steps, and many tailgate partiers may find their feet resting on the ground. Revolutionary.

time to read

5 mins

Winter 2026

Motor Trend

Motor Trend

Mercedes-AMG CLE 53 Cabriolet

PROS A special car that makes you feel special Handsome styling Luxurious interior CONS High style = high price Capacitive steering wheel buttons MBUX infotainment

time to read

2 mins

Winter 2026

Motor Trend

Motor Trend

Subaru Solterra

PROS Powerful standard all-wheel drive • Balanced ride and handling • Distinctive interior styling CONS Toyota bZ's superior tuning • Average range and slow charging • Weird interior layout

time to read

2 mins

Winter 2026

Translate

Share

-
+

Change font size