Peak COMFORT
New York magazine|July 6-19, 2020
The triumph of brazenly uncomplicated entertainment.
KATHRYN VANARENDONK
Peak COMFORT

ONE OF THE BEST NEW TV SHOWS I’ve seen lately is the Netflix adaptation of the beloved YA book series The Baby-Sitters Club. I like the show for lots of reasons, but chief among them is how genuine it is about the things that matter to its group of young protagonists. Creating a show like that—one that can confidently deliver a warm, sincere, thoughtful tone without coming off as simplistic or self-congratulatory, that will appeal to multiple age groups, and that can pull off a “girl’s first period” plot without feeling gross or pedagogical—is impressive. It takes skill. It’s an excellent season of TV.

There’s a different version of that first sentence, one I might have written if I were reviewing The Baby-Sitters Club even a few years ago. Rather than best, I would likely have swapped in the word favorite. It’s a small but meaningful distinction. Best is always a bit of a lie in criticism, a way to pretend a critic’s subjectivity can be removed from the equation, but it is an important signifier nonetheless. It’s an indicator of quality. The term means “I think this is good, not just for me but objectively for lots of people.” Favorite may be truer, but it also comes off as a qualification: “I enjoyed this show. Maybe you will too?”

This story is from the July 6-19, 2020 edition of New York magazine.

Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.

This story is from the July 6-19, 2020 edition of New York magazine.

Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.

MORE STORIES FROM NEW YORK MAGAZINEView All
Adelle Waldman Takes the Early Shift
New York magazine

Adelle Waldman Takes the Early Shift

In 2013, she published a novel that literary Brooklyn couldn’t stop talking about. It took a $12.25-an-hour job at a retail store to write the next one.

time-read
10+ mins  |
March 11-24, 2024
BIG FEELINGS
New York magazine

BIG FEELINGS

Its made her the most influential parenting expert since Dr. Spock.

time-read
10+ mins  |
March 11-24, 2024
THE SQUATTERS OF BEVERLY HILLS
New York magazine

THE SQUATTERS OF BEVERLY HILLS

AFTER A FUGITIVE DOCTOR ABANDONED HIS MANSION, AN ENTERPRISING GROUP OF PARTY THROWERS MANAGED TO SLIDE IN THROUGH THE FRONT DOOR, UPENDING THE COMFORTABLE LIVES OF THEIR NEW, ULTRAWEALTHY NEIGHBORS.

time-read
10+ mins  |
March 11-24, 2024
THE RIGHT ΤΟ CHANGE SEX
New York magazine

THE RIGHT ΤΟ CHANGE SEX

Trans kids are under attack. It’s time we found the courage to defend them.

time-read
10+ mins  |
March 11-24, 2024
Dynasties: Tanya Gold Fall of the House of Windsor The crisis behind the tabloid sensation surrounding Princess Catherine.
New York magazine

Dynasties: Tanya Gold Fall of the House of Windsor The crisis behind the tabloid sensation surrounding Princess Catherine.

TO OUTSIDERS, the British royal family can seem like a curio.

time-read
5 mins  |
March 11-24, 2024
192 MINUTES WITH ...Reesa Teesa
New York magazine

192 MINUTES WITH ...Reesa Teesa

The \"Who TF Did I Marry\" TikToker, whose tale of a lying husband went megaviral, says she won't be fooled again.

time-read
6 mins  |
March 11-24, 2024
Neighborhood News: Soldiers in the Subway
New York magazine

Neighborhood News: Soldiers in the Subway

The governor sends in the troops.

time-read
1 min  |
March 11-24, 2024
The System: Zak Cheney-Rice
New York magazine

The System: Zak Cheney-Rice

But His Crimes... Are voters forgetting the extraordinary accusations against Trump?

time-read
5 mins  |
March 11-24, 2024
The Crying Game: Weeping on Cue is the Toughest Skill an Actor Can Learn. Could I Do It, Too?
New York magazine

The Crying Game: Weeping on Cue is the Toughest Skill an Actor Can Learn. Could I Do It, Too?

Crying has been one of the most popular activities of the past four to eight years; the ability to do it on command has been considered the apex of acting ability for much longer. Consider the 2017 Decider investigation that revealed 96 percent of Best Actress winners over the past 50 years openly wept during their performances (compared with 60 percent of Best Actor winners, thanks to boring yet pervasive sociological dynamics that have long poisoned the human experience).

time-read
10+ mins  |
February 26 - March 10, 2024
Performance Review: Allison P. Davis
New York magazine

Performance Review: Allison P. Davis

Endless Love: J.Lo returns to her rom-com roots. Is she tired of repeating herself?

time-read
6 mins  |
February 26 - March 10, 2024