
You write in the introduction about Antonio Gramsci’s “a time of monsters”, and term the extreme weather events of today to be such monsters. What prompted you to think of this analogy?
These are not just weather events. They are also political ones. When Gramsci talked about one order having died and another one waiting to be born, and in between there being the time of monsters, he was talking about fascists; purely political creatures, if you like.
But now, we also have these purely environmental monsters which are also purely political because climate change itself is intensely political. It arises out of national inequalities and extreme geopolitical hierarchies. So we can no longer say they are just environmental disasters. They are, in some profound sense, political disasters.
How do you see current climate politics and negotiations from the prism of your statement?
I do not know if that came as a surprise to anyone. It certainly did not come as a surprise to me. It was perfectly self-evident that they were going to fail because what these negotiations are essentially centred on is preserving inequalities. The status quo powers want to preserve their great privileges in the world. Obviously, those who were under-privileged before, do not want that situation to continue. I think that is the juncture or dead wall that is impossible to pass beyond. The affluent countries of the West repeatedly say there is no money for climate mitigation. They offered a very trivial sum for mitigation. At the same time, they are increasing their defence spending by leaps and bounds. It is actually unimaginable how they are able to do this. None of it makes any sense.
Climate change and migration are two cognate aspects of the same thing, you write. Could you elaborate?
This story is from the February 01, 2025 edition of Down To Earth.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber ? Sign In
This story is from the February 01, 2025 edition of Down To Earth.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In

Invisibilised localities
AN ETHNOGRAPHIC STUDY ON THE NETWORKS, CULTURAL TRADITIONS AND OBSTACLES FACED BY RESIDENTS OF JHUGGIS AND TRANSIT CAMPS WHILE DEALING WITH EVICTION POLITICS AND INEQUALITIES IN DELHI

TUNNEL VISION
Bengaluru's civic body must ascertain suitability of the city's geology before moving ahead with its tunnel road project for seamless travel

SAFETY IN CIRCULARITY
Global standards of water availability show that India is water stressed. Reusing treated wastewater can augment water supply while solving the problem of its safe disposal. FARAZ AHMAD and SUMITA SINGHAL analyse wastewater management practices of 16 cities in seven states to understand the challenges and potential areas of reuse

AGAINST THE GRAIN
India's two most valuable timbers-sandalwood and red sanders-have long been bound by restrictive regulations designed to curb illegal trade. Encouraged by the government decades ago with promises of windfall profits, farmers took to commercial cultivation, investing years of patience and effort. Now, as they prepare to harvest, a harsh reality is setting in-the promise of big profits is not quite holding up. HIMANSHU NITNAWARE travels to 19 villages across Karnataka, Andhra Pradesh and Telangana to explore the reasons

Guardians of forest
Communities across Maharashtra take on the mantle of biodiversity conservation; replicate sacred groves on common land

Climate talks
Anil Agarwal Dialogue 2025 sees discussions on the state of India's environment, energy ambitions and emerging health threats

Mission for inclusion
Vidya Rajput leads the fight for transgender community's rights and acceptance in Chhattisgarh

Ready for power shift
An unprecedented drought forces hydropower- dependent Zambia to diversify its energy portfolio, embrace solar power

THE GREAT FARM HUSTLE
Agroforestry is fast emerging as a win-win strategy to mitigate climate change and improve farmers' income. It is particularly so in India, home to one-fifth of the agroforestry carbon projects in the world. Over the past months ROHINI KRISHNAMURTHY has travelled to almost 20 villages across the country to understand how this market works. At all locations, she finds that communities and their land and labour are central to the projects. But they do not always benefit from the carbon revenue

CAN AGROFORESTRY CREDITS BE SAVED?
Ensure that farmers benefit from the carbon revenue and stay protected against market failure