THE DAY THE MUSIC DIED

Is popular culture really in terminal decline?

- Spencer Kornhaber

Last year, I visited the music historian Ted Gioia to talk about the death of civilization.

He welcomed me into his suburban-Texas home and showed me to a sunlit library. At the center of the room, arranged neatly on a countertop, stood 41 books. These, he said, were the books I needed to read.

The display included all seven volumes of Edward Gibbon's 18th-century opus, The Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire; both volumes of Oswald Spengler's World War I-era tract, The Decline of the West; and a 2,500-year-old account of the Peloponnesian War by Thucydides, who "was the first historian to look at his own culture, Greece, and say, I'm going to tell you the story of how stupid we were," Gioia explained.

Gioia's contributions to this lineage of doomsaying have made him into something of an internet celebrity. For most of his career, he was best-known for writing about jazz. But with his Substack newsletter, The Honest Broker, he's attracted a large and avid readership by taking on contemporary culture-and arguing that it's terrible. America's "creative energy" has been sapped, he told me, and the results can be seen in the diminished quality of arts and entertainment, with knock-on effects to the country's happiness and even its political stability.