AN ENQUIRY INTO THE ROLE OF MARKET INTERMEDIARIES IN INDIA'S ONION CRISIS
The Management Accountant|November 2020
This paper assesses the extent to which market intermediaries have been responsible for the crisis that onion markets have witnessed in the past few years. The paper found that commission agents and wholesalers frequently indulge in price manipulation to purchase onions at predecided prices instead of at auction prices. Big traders attempt to prevent entry of new traders in the market by utilising their market dominance, in order to limit market competition. Traders may also have resorted to hoarding of onions to take advantage of its price rise. This led to an artificial shortage of onions in the retail markets. Imposing of high margins by retailers also has caused sudden spikes in onion prices in retail markets.
Avishek Roy
AN ENQUIRY INTO THE ROLE OF MARKET INTERMEDIARIES IN INDIA'S ONION CRISIS

INTRODUCTION

In the last couple of years, onion prices have seen wide fluctuations. Onions are staple ingredient of Indian cooking. Rise in its prices causes distress to large sections of the population, especially the poor. This makes onion a “politically sensitive crop”(Chengappa et al(2012)Pg58). Apparently, unseasonal rains had curtailed supplies leading to a price rise. However, media reports have alleged that the shortage was artificial, as wholesalers had hoarded large stocks of onion. Academic papers that analysed patterns of onion arrivals in wholesale markets and onion prices (wholesale and retail) have made similar observations.

Onion farmers seldom benefit from an increase in its retail prices. Intermediaries (or middlemen) in the onion supply chain leverage their superior access to information or material resources and collude among themselves to prevent farmers of realising the best possible price for selling their harvest. By exploiting imperfections already existing in the regulated wholesale markets and by utilising their connections with market officials,intermediaries are sometime able to attain monopoly powers in these markets. As intermediaries continue pursuing policies for strengthening their stranglehold on the markets, farmers are made increasingly vulnerable. On the other hand, hoarding of onions by wholesalers and imposing of high mark-ups by the retailers increases its retail prices. This lands consumers are in extreme hardship.

This paper analyses the role played by commission agents, wholesalers and retailers in deepening the onion crisis by depriving farmers of a fair price for selling onions; and also by making onions exorbitantly expensive for consumers.

This story is from the November 2020 edition of The Management Accountant.

Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.

This story is from the November 2020 edition of The Management Accountant.

Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.

MORE STORIES FROM THE MANAGEMENT ACCOUNTANTView All
UNVEILING DIGITAL HEALTH AND ELECTRONIC HEALTH RECORD THE IMPENDING MECHANISMS TO AMELIORATE HEALTHCARE EFFICACY IN INDIA
The Management Accountant

UNVEILING DIGITAL HEALTH AND ELECTRONIC HEALTH RECORD THE IMPENDING MECHANISMS TO AMELIORATE HEALTHCARE EFFICACY IN INDIA

With sustainable economic growth potential and foreseeable improvement in public service delivery, India needs instruments to improve sectoral productivity in healthcare. In the modern world of technological advancements, digital intervention is inevitable to increase healthcare effectiveness. Digital health includes multiple digital care mediations ensuring the convergence of digital technologies with wellness, treatment, healthcare, and society to improve the efficacy of service delivery and make medicines more explicit and user-specific.

time-read
6 mins  |
February 2021
IMPLEMENTING AN INTEGRATED HOSPITAL COST MANAGEMENT SYSTEM
The Management Accountant

IMPLEMENTING AN INTEGRATED HOSPITAL COST MANAGEMENT SYSTEM

The unique features of Healthcare Sector and their Business Process Flow are a big challenge to implement an Integrated Cost Management Solution. Even though a Hospital may have an effective Medical Information System of Patients and an ERP, they still struggle with implementing a Costing System; this is because the information is in different Silos. To implement an effective Costing System, the cost structure should be either inbuilt in the ERP or should have information flowing in from the Accounting and Patient Information. Identifying the Cost Elements and their classification, defining Cost Objects and their hierarchy and mapping the flow of information from Accounting and Medical Information System are pre-requisite for an Integrated Cost Management Solution. With the rapid development in information technology many IT firms/ERP use Data Connectivity for seamless integration. An integrated Costing System will facilitate online reporting and help Management in decision making on Pricing, Profitability and Cost Control.

time-read
8 mins  |
February 2021
The Management Accountant

INAUGURATION OF LONDON OVERSEAS CENTRE OF COST ACCOUNTANTS ON 23rd JANUARY 2021

On the auspicious occasion of 125th birth anniversary of Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose on 23rd January or ‘Parakram Diwas’ this year, The Institute of Cost Accountants of India added a feather in its cap through the grand opening of London Overseas Centre of Cost Accountants (LOCCA), the first ever European centre in the heart of London. It was highly supported by British Deputy High Commission, Kolkata, India Business Group and UK India Business Council.

time-read
6 mins  |
February 2021
EMPLOYEE WELLNESS PROGRAM: ITS BENEFITS SURPASS ITS COST
The Management Accountant

EMPLOYEE WELLNESS PROGRAM: ITS BENEFITS SURPASS ITS COST

When a person falls ill, it costs a lot not only in monetary terms but also in terms of his mental well-being. Not only the person who has fallen ill suffers, his family, friends also have to suffer because of his illness. The same logic applies to an organization also. When an employee falls ill, the whole organization suffers. In order to avoid such damages and disturbances, precautions are to be taken. For that, employee wellness program is a great panacea. Employee Wellness Program is the program run by an employer in order to improve employee health and also to help an individual employee to overcome any specific health related issue. So, the organizations should implement such Employee Wellness Programs to reap the benefits of the same. In this article, how Employee Wellness Programs can be executed, types of wellness programs and their benefits are discussed.

time-read
7 mins  |
February 2021
DIGITAL TRANSFORMATION ADVANCEMENTS IN APPLICATIONS OF BLOCKCHAIN TECHNOLOGY THE EVOLVING POWERHOUSE OF INDUSTRY 4.0
The Management Accountant

DIGITAL TRANSFORMATION ADVANCEMENTS IN APPLICATIONS OF BLOCKCHAIN TECHNOLOGY THE EVOLVING POWERHOUSE OF INDUSTRY 4.0

The idea for processing transactions in a cryptographically secured chain of blocks was first revealed in 1991 by computer scientists Stuart Haber and W. S. Stornetta.

time-read
10 mins  |
February 2021
MSME And Its Impact On Indian Economy
The Management Accountant

MSME And Its Impact On Indian Economy

Abstract Small businesses are the backbone of any economy. Micro, small and medium enterprises provide employment and economic opportunities to millions of Indians. The growth of MSME will bring the underprivileged to a good position in the economy. Instead of making the rich richer, overall growth will make a prosperous India.

time-read
5 mins  |
December 2020
Government Procurement From MSME's The Present & The Future
The Management Accountant

Government Procurement From MSME's The Present & The Future

Abstract The MSMEs in India are considered to be the real engines of growth for the economy and their healthy participation in Government Procurement will have its own beneficial spin offs to the society. Government is doing a lot to encourage them but still some more things will empower these lilliputs to become economic giants and contribute in nation building.

time-read
5 mins  |
December 2020
VISION OF “ATMA NIRBHAR BHARAT” ROLE AND SIGNIFICANCE OF MSME
The Management Accountant

VISION OF “ATMA NIRBHAR BHARAT” ROLE AND SIGNIFICANCE OF MSME

The present paper aims to explore the changing role of MSMEs (Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises) in making India ‘Atmanirbhar’.

time-read
8 mins  |
December 2020
REVIVAL OF MSMEs (POST COVID-19) STRATEGY OF CMAs
The Management Accountant

REVIVAL OF MSMEs (POST COVID-19) STRATEGY OF CMAs

Abstract There has been an unprecedented slowdown due to Covid-19 and MSMEs are worst affected. Given their pivotal role in Indian economy, urgent measures need to be taken for their survival, revival and growth. Indian Government has taken various initiatives including Atma Nirbhar Package, however, still majority MSMEs are looking for timely guidance and hand holding at this critical phase. CMAs are known for rich experience in finance, domain expertise in cost management and sound knowledge of Indian regulatory mechanism. CMAs can play role as ‘Economic Warrior’ while offering customised strategy for revival of ailing MSMEs which will in turn boost up economic growth and help our grand nation to be ‘USD 5 Trillion’ economy soon.

time-read
7 mins  |
December 2020
MICRO, SMALL & MEDIUM ENTERPRISES IN NEW TECHNOLOGICAL ERA CHALLENGES & ROAD AHEAD
The Management Accountant

MICRO, SMALL & MEDIUM ENTERPRISES IN NEW TECHNOLOGICAL ERA CHALLENGES & ROAD AHEAD

Abstract We live in the world which is rapidly changing due to technological advancements. The technological advancements lead to fourth industry revolution which is known as “Industry 4.0”. This digital revolution is changing the business models of all manufacturing & service industries whether it is large, small or medium. The need of adopting latest and modern technology is realised not only for large scale industries even small and medium size industries to compete in global market.

time-read
7 mins  |
December 2020