Poging GOUD - Vrij

What Makes A Work Of Art Great?

Philosophy Now

|

August/September 2025

Each answer below receives a book. Apologies to all the entrants not included.

Great art must score highly on four measures: emotional impact (visual and visceral); technique (masterful and harmonious); concept (relevant or timeless); and originality (of medium, subject, or treatment).

There are many ways each of these criteria can be satisfied, both subjectively and objectively, but the media are open-ended. One can build great architecture; paint on canvas or a wall; sculpt wood, rock, or beach; project an image on a building or the Moon; make an installation; stage a happening... The media extend to literature, music, stage, and film. Even engineering is not entirely bound to functionality. A ship, aircraft, or bridge can satisfy all the 'great art' criteria, even if stirring emotion was no part of the designer's intention.

To be art, a work has to be made deliberately by a person (assuming AI art is necessarily derivative), and witnessable in principle by anyone. To have meaning it needs a context wider than its content. An abstract canvas needs a perceptive apparatus. A painting or photograph whose natural subject has been carefully selected owes to the physical setting and human expectations. Does this mean there are boundaries to what anyone should consider art? The way art has developed historically, though decoration, statuary, performance, religious scenes, portraiture and landscapes, to conceptual art - supports this. But boundaries evolve, and then the question is, how far? An entertainment in sixteenth century Paris involved collecting cats in a bag, hoisting them up in a public square, and lighting a fire underneath. Was that

Philosophy Now

Dit verhaal komt uit de August/September 2025-editie van Philosophy Now.

Abonneer u op Magzter GOLD voor toegang tot duizenden zorgvuldig samengestelde premiumverhalen en meer dan 9000 tijdschriften en kranten.

Bent u al abonnee?

MEER VERHALEN VAN Philosophy Now

Philosophy Now

Philosophy Now

Pharmaco-Metaphysics?

Raymond Tallis argues against acidic assertions, and doubts DMT discoveries.

time to read

7 mins

August/September 2025

Philosophy Now

Philosophy Now

Nine Spiritual Exercises

Massimo Pigliucci explains how to get Philo-Sophical.

time to read

3 mins

August/September 2025

Philosophy Now

Philosophy Now

Books

We follow mammal's search for meaning, as Mark Vorobej savages John Gray's book of impractical cat philosophy, while B.V.E. Hyde ponders the point of Jordan Peterson. In Classics, Hilarius Bogbinder reviews Plato's Republic.

time to read

21 mins

August/September 2025

Philosophy Now

Philosophy Now

The Centennial of the Scopes ‘Monkey’ Trial

Tim Madigan on the creation and the evolution of a legend.

time to read

14 mins

August/September 2025

Philosophy Now

Philosophy Now

Gödel, Wittgenstein, & the Limits of Knowledge

Michael D. McGranahan takes us to the edge of language, mathematics and science.

time to read

10 mins

August/September 2025

Philosophy Now

Philosophy Now

Weltschmerz and the World

Ian James Kidd takes a realistic and global view of the history of pessimism.

time to read

10 mins

August/September 2025

Philosophy Now

What Makes A Work Of Art Great?

Each answer below receives a book. Apologies to all the entrants not included.

time to read

16 mins

August/September 2025

Philosophy Now

Philosophy Now

The Beatles: Nothing is Real

Clinton Van Inman gets back to the psychedelic Sixties.

time to read

4 mins

August/September 2025

Philosophy Now

Philosophy Now

The Post-Truth Kerfuffle

Susan Haack, who is Distinguished Professor in the Humanities, Cooper Senior Scholar in Arts & Sciences, Professor of Philosophy, and Professor of Law, at the University of Miami, talks with Angela Tan about how and when we know.

time to read

11 mins

August/September 2025

Philosophy Now

Philosophy Now

A Crisis of Attention

Paul Doolan attends to our culture of attention demanding.

time to read

13 mins

August/September 2025

Listen

Translate

Share

-
+

Change font size