Prøve GULL - Gratis

Minister is unable to say which changing room trans women can use after ruling

The Independent

|

April 18, 2025

A government minister was unable to say which changing room transgender women should use after the Supreme Court ruled they are not legally women under the Equality Act.

- MILLIE COOKE POLITICAL CORRESPONDENT

Minister is unable to say which changing room trans women can use after ruling

The judgment, handed down on Wednesday, means transgender women with a gender recognition certificate can be excluded from single-sex spaces if deemed “proportionate”.

But asked which changing room a transgender woman should use, Labour health minister Karin Smyth could not say.

“Look, I think we need to make sure that in this discussion we are following both the law so that is clear for women and for service providers and you know... this varies upon what the provision of those service providers are. Large organisations, smaller organisations, many smaller organisations,” she told Times Radio.

Asked why it varies, Ms Smyth responded: “Because some will have unisex provisions. There might only be one bathroom, one changing room in an organisation. It’s a large complex issue so that’s why people have to be very clear on that guidance.”

When it was put to her that the public is looking for clarity from the government, she said: “Female changing rooms should be used by women.”

FLERE HISTORIER FRA The Independent

The Independent

The Independent

Scotland withstand Greek attacks in epic comeback

Lewis Ferguson netted his first Scotland goal as Steve Clarke's side came from behind to beat Greece 3-1 and maintain their promising start to their World Cup qualifying campaign.

time to read

2 mins

October 10, 2025

The Independent

The Independent

Macron on 'last chance' as he clears way for latest PM

French president Emmanuel Macron is set to name his sixth prime minister in less than two years, hoping the new appointment can navigate a budget through a deeply divided legislature.

time to read

2 mins

October 10, 2025

The Independent

The Independent

The shocking truth about the 'ordinary' killer Nazi

In an infamous picture from the Second World War, an SS soldier blithely prepares to shoot a Jewish prisoner. The murderer's identity has finally been revealed and shows what can happen when we lose our humanity, writes Guy Walters

time to read

6 mins

October 10, 2025

The Independent

The Independent

'I always knew that she wasn't my sister Madeleine'

Amelie McCann gives evidence in trial of alleged stalker

time to read

3 mins

October 10, 2025

The Independent

The Independent

SOUND AND VISION

Peter Doig's House of Music exhibition at the Serpentine South Gallery combines the world's most influential painter's twin passions of art and music, writes Mark Hudson

time to read

3 mins

October 10, 2025

The Independent

The Independent

'Finally, a good morning'

Joy was widespread in both Gaza and Israel as Trump's deal was agreed - but caution around the fragile peace remains

time to read

3 mins

October 10, 2025

The Independent

The Independent

Former civil servants find PM's China take 'puzzling'

Ex-national security adviser says superpower always a theat

time to read

2 mins

October 10, 2025

The Independent

The Independent

Benefit loans trap 500,000 children in cycle of poverty

Families borrow cash as they wait weeks for first payment

time to read

3 mins

October 10, 2025

The Independent

The Independent

Israel and Hamas take their first step towards peace

Aid set to surge into Gaza as remaining hostages are released

time to read

4 mins

October 10, 2025

The Independent

The Independent

China sees UK concessions as weakness, not diplomacy

The government's failure to act against alleged Beijing spies shows a worrying lack of spine, writes Mark L Clifford

time to read

5 mins

October 10, 2025

Listen

Translate

Share

-
+

Change font size