Facebook Pixel Our understanding of NCAP stars is too simplistic. To avoid commonly held and potentially dangerous misconceptions, Srini lists twelve things you must know about car safety ratings. | autoX - automotive - Les denne historien på Magzter.com
Gå ubegrenset med Magzter GOLD

Gå ubegrenset med Magzter GOLD

Få ubegrenset tilgang til over 9000 magasiner, aviser og premiumhistorier for bare

$149.99
 
$74.99/År

Prøve GULL - Gratis

Our understanding of NCAP stars is too simplistic. To avoid commonly held and potentially dangerous misconceptions, Srini lists twelve things you must know about car safety ratings.

autoX

|

January 2026

Very often, we simply look at the Global or Bharat New Car Assessment Programme (NCAP) star ratings and immediately jump to various conclusions.

- by SRINIVAS KRISHNAN

Our understanding of NCAP stars is too simplistic. To avoid commonly held and potentially dangerous misconceptions, Srini lists twelve things you must know about car safety ratings.

Sometimes these conclusions can be injurious to health. For instance, you may think that, if you are driving around in a 5-star rated car, then you are invincible and that nothing can happen. But nasty things do happen, right? Even occupants of the most well-engineered/safety-feature-equipped cars perish in crashes... What gives? And does a car with 3 stars or below mean it's an unsafe car? Some occupants emerge unscathed from crashes, while some don't from the same model of car - why? Can you trust a list of 'the safest cars in India' based on the number of stars? It's time to bust some myths, and reveal some untold facts.

In my last column, I highlighted how Bharat NCAP 2.0 differs from the previous version (autoX.com/opinion) and is for the better. This time around, as promised, is the second part on safety ratings and new car assessment programmes.

The objective of this column is to clear some perceptions and share some undisclosed information about GNCAP/BNCAP safety ratings, so that you don't fall prey to marketing spiel. Most OEMs tom-tom their safety ratings and give you the impression that you are driving a Main Battle Tank. Well, they are not to be blamed, as these safety ratings – while highly important and critical – also function as marketing collateral, mainly because the ratings given after tests are conducted by an independent third party. But as a prospective car buyer or user, you need to understand the nuances of star ratings - the really important stuff the ads leave out.

I've had long conversations on road safety with a professional automotive and road safety engineer and researcher who goes by the anonymous handle @RSGuy_India, and he has been generous in allowing me to adapt his blog on this topic. So here goes...

FLERE HISTORIER FRA autoX

autoX

autoX

DOWN TO THE WIRE

The competition was fierce, but in the end, the championship was won by just two points.

time to read

2 mins

January 2026

autoX

autoX

HISTORY HITS REFRESH

The Tata Sierra nameplate coming back is now old news. The question to be asked is – will it pose a problem for its rivals, old and new? We believe it will.

time to read

4 mins

January 2026

autoX

autoX

ADAS THIRD EYE 3.0

India's Top-6 car manufacturers slug it out for top honours in the 3rd edition of our Mega ADAS Test.

time to read

13 mins

January 2026

autoX

autoX

APEX PREDATOR

Realme's new Dream Edition smartphone promises more power and performance at a significant premium. But does it truly justify the price it commands?

time to read

3 mins

January 2026

autoX

autoX

ESTABLISHING STANDARDS

The Vingroup of companies have made a bold entry into India and it all begins with the launch of VinFast cars.

time to read

2 mins

January 2026

autoX

autoX

OLD SOUL NEW SUIT

On paper, it looks like the most approachable way to enjoy Yamaha's brilliant 155cc motor. But is that really the case?

time to read

3 mins

January 2026

autoX

autoX

TAIL TIDY

The X440 T combines the iconic XR1200's styling with ride-by-wire refinement. The result is a roadster that finally looks as mean as it rides.

time to read

2 mins

January 2026

autoX

autoX

REINVENTING SUCCESS

We find out if the new Seltos can reclaim its benchmark status in a segment that's more competitive than ever.

time to read

4 mins

January 2026

autoX

autoX

UPCOMING CARS & BIKES OF 2026

The new year promises to have a bunch of high-octane car and bike launches and these are almost certain to hit Indian shores.

time to read

7 mins

January 2026

autoX

autoX

ELECTRIFYING INDIA

With its first EV, can the country's largest carmaker accelerate EV adoption in India? We test the new e Vitara to find out.

time to read

4 mins

January 2026

Listen

Translate

Share

-
+

Change font size