Why England's golden run ended at house of horrors

Scotland's dismantling of Borthwick's 12-game unbeaten side raises key questions about its away form and team selection

- HARRY LATHAM-COYLE RUGBY CORRESPONDENT

For England rugby, it was a Valentine's evening to forget. There was a novel feeling to post-match proceedings as a side that had learned how not to lose remembered again how it felt to fall short; after an extended honeymoon period in the forging of a new identity through a run of 12 wins, here was the sort of showing that Steve Borthwick’s side had perhaps been due.

Cue talk of a learning experience, of taking the positives, of building back better, a once-familiar script returned to. “It is frustrating,” centre Fraser Dingwall said, before belabouring the point, using that word seven times in two minutes as he collected the thoughts of a muddled mind. He, and the rest of his England colleagues, could identify what went wrong - aerial inferiority, red-zone inefficiency, high-profile errors - but not really articulate why.

The straightforward solution would be to strike a performance like this from the record; a setback, yes, but an aberration when viewed as part of a rather more positive body of evidence 12 months long. Yet as England gathered after the match, there must have been a galling feel of another haunting night at their Edinburgh house of horrors. Why always here? Why always them? “I think if you look at Scotland, obviously they had a frustrating result last week against Italy, but they bounced back really well and they’re a quality side,” the scrum half Alex Mitchell suggested. “They've showed that for the last couple of years. We’ve not got a result here in however long, but it’s one of them. It’s tough to take.”