Intentar ORO - Gratis

Matters at hand: VAR has magnified handball injustices - it's time to adjust the penalties

The Guardian

|

November 08, 2024

The first draft of this column began with me rehashing one of my three anecdotes. Not the microwave or the six-pound peach, the one where I ranted on TalkSport about how repetitive and boring the Lord of the Rings films are to the point where the boss texted to ask whether I'd ever considered being so energised about football.

- Max Rushden

Matters at hand: VAR has magnified handball injustices - it's time to adjust the penalties

So it was with some disappointment when the editor sent this back to say I had used the same story TWO WEEKS AGO - literally my previous column! Nothing like repetition when criticising something for being repetitive. If I was smarter, I could say I meant it.

Perhaps the cupboard is now bare for my writing career, but the anecdote illustrates how rarely I get truly angry about sport. The hyperbolic sensationalism of almost every aspect of football gets pretty tiring pretty quickly. Play your "The game's gone" card carefully - surely you can only use it once.

Occasionally a moment can move me to the point of tears, even if it doesn't push me over the edge. Staying up on the final day. Winning at St James' Park in the FA Cup. Watching Stuart Pearce's penalty against Spain in Euro 96 over and over again.

But defeats seem to get less painful as I get older. Perceived refereeing injustices have always just been a bit annoying, as opposed to an excuse to boil inside for days. Anger over sport seems misplaced when we are confronted by the horrors of real life across the world.

However, what I like to think is a measured, almost superior way of watching sport collapses as soon as I see yet another penalty awarded for handball. Such is the blind fury at these decisions that I've lost all sense of what handball is - getting to the stage where I wouldn't penalise Luis Suarez against Ghana.

MÁS HISTORIAS DE The Guardian

The Guardian

The Guardian

'Heroic' rail worker in fight for life after tackling train knife attacker

Single suspect held over stabbings as 11 victims are treated in hospital

time to read

3 mins

November 03, 2025

The Guardian

World Cup wave leaves Saracens riding high in the sun

The stars came out to dazzle a record Saracens crowd in a 47-10 derby win for the home side against Harlequins

time to read

3 mins

November 03, 2025

The Guardian

The Guardian

Goal machine Haaland's latest double fires City up to second

But Guardiola still criticises refereeing standards at Etihad by saying: They're brave here’

time to read

1 mins

November 03, 2025

The Guardian

The Guardian

Southampton sack Still as club slide into the danger zone

Southampton have sacked Will Still after the club dropped closer to the Championship relegation zone.

time to read

1 min

November 03, 2025

The Guardian

UK workforce risks loss of extra 600,000 people to poor health - study

An extra 600,000 people will leave the workforce in the next decade because of long-term health conditions unless there is \"a fundamental shift\" in how employers help maintain staff well-being, a report says.

time to read

1 mins

November 03, 2025

The Guardian

The Guardian

Nuno hails fans as Hammers hit back in rare win

Nuno Espírito Santo said that his West Ham team had given their fans “something small” to cling on to with a first victory of his tenure and that he hoped a performance of grit, ability and, perhaps most importantly, belief would give them momentum in their fight against relegation.

time to read

3 mins

November 03, 2025

The Guardian

The Guardian

Cycles of power The young bike fans reclaiming the streets of Johannesburg

On a hot Saturday spring morning, Karabo Mashele urged a group of female cyclists up the hills of a plush Johannesburg suburb.

time to read

3 mins

November 03, 2025

The Guardian

The Guardian

Shafali and Deepti the home heroes as India make history

Wolvaardt hits another hundred but South Africa pay for dropped catches in final

time to read

3 mins

November 03, 2025

The Guardian

The Guardian

Reeves is warned not to cut VAT on electricity bills

Proposals being considered by Rachel Reeves to cut tax on electricity bills will backfire, experts have warned, resulting in a giveaway to richer homeowners and undermining the UK's climate commitments.

time to read

3 mins

November 03, 2025

The Guardian

Wolves eye O'Neil and Edwards after Pereira exits

Wolves could turn to their former head coach Gary O'Neil after sacking Vítor Pereira, with Middlesbrough's Rob Edwards another leading candidate.

time to read

2 mins

November 03, 2025

Listen

Translate

Share

-
+

Change font size