Intentar ORO - Gratis

Bommai judgment draws the line for democracy

Hindustan Times Amritsar

|

July 17, 2025

Indian politics is no stranger to power strug- gles, party splits, and mid-term shake-ups. But when this starts affecting elected state governments, constitutional principles — and institutions — are tested.

- Ashish Bharadwaj Insiyah Vahanvaty

Indian politics is no stranger to power struggles, party splits, and midterm shakeups. But when this starts affecting elected state governments, constitutional principles — and institutions — are tested. One of the most important cases to ever deal with this was SR Bommai vs. Union of India, 1994. A constitutional firewall against arbitrary dismissal of elected governments, it asa landmarkruling. ‘And yet, the 2022 Maharashtra crisis involving the Shiv Sena split showed how political machinations can strain even the strongest constitutional guardrails.

But first, what was the Bommai case? SR Bommai was the Chief Minister of Karnataka. His party had recently undergone a merger, leading to political instability. A few legislators were said to have withdrawn support. The governor quickly concluded that Bommai no longer enjoyed a majority and advised the President to dismiss the government. Crucially, Bommai was not allowed to prove his majority in the Assembly — there was no floor test. But this wasn't an isolated case. By then, Article 356 of the Constitution — which allows the Centre to dismiss a state government if it fails to function according to constitutional norms — had been used 95 times. Sometimes legitimately, but often as a political tool to unseat opposition governments.

MÁS HISTORIAS DE Hindustan Times Amritsar

Hindustan Times Amritsar

Hindustan Times Amritsar

The power of youth: Welcome to Indian cricket's Gill-Jaiswal era

Young skipper and opener have stamped their class in Tests over the last 2 years

time to read

4 mins

October 12, 2025

Hindustan Times Amritsar

Elderly women need focussed interventions

October 1 is observed as World Elder Day, with all its attendant focus on the needs of older people and their potential. It is a day that comes by only to be forgotten quickly and the spotlight moves back onto the potential India's younger demographic holds. In the cohort of older persons, women are most at a disadvantage.

time to read

2 mins

October 12, 2025

Hindustan Times Amritsar

Hindustan Times Amritsar

Modi launches two agri schemes worth ₹35k-cr

Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Saturday said that the reforms in agriculture and farming sectors undertaken by the Union government in the last 11 years have begun to show results, but for speedy development of the country, these sectors will need to be strengthened further.

time to read

1 mins

October 12, 2025

Hindustan Times Amritsar

Hindustan Times Amritsar

Canadian foreign min to arrive today; trade, security ties in focus

Canada and India will look at \"establishing a framework for strategic cooperation\" in areas of trade, energy and security during Canadian foreign affairs minister Anita Anand's visit to New Delhi starting Sunday.

time to read

1 min

October 12, 2025

Hindustan Times Amritsar

VISCERA REPORT OF ZUBEEN GARG RECEIVED: POLICE

Biswa Kalyan Purkayastha letters@hindustantimes.com

time to read

1 min

October 12, 2025

Hindustan Times Amritsar

NDA likely to announce seat-sharing deal today

'NO DIFFERENCES AMONG ALLIES'

time to read

2 mins

October 12, 2025

Hindustan Times Amritsar

World can’t let critical minerals go the oil way

Energy transition must be fair, equitable and just, leaving nobody behind. The governance of critical minerals must evolve in response to this context

time to read

5 mins

October 12, 2025

Hindustan Times Amritsar

DEOBAND SEMINARY CONFERS TALIBAN'S MUTTAQI WITH 'HADITH SANAD'

Taliban foreign minister Amir Khan Muttaqi was on Saturday conferred with the \"Hadith Sanad\" (certificate of authority) by Darul Uloom Deoband, one of the most influential Islamic seminaries in South Asia.

time to read

1 min

October 12, 2025

Hindustan Times Amritsar

Simran likely to lose para Worlds medals

Days after India celebrated its biggest medal haul at the World Para Athletics Championships here, the guide of woman sprinter Simran Sharma, Umar Saifi, was provisionally suspended by the National AntiDoping Agency (NADA).

time to read

1 min

October 12, 2025

Hindustan Times Amritsar

Govt plans to exempt green nod for solid waste facilities

THE CENTRE PROPOSED TO EXEMPT THESE SECTORS BECAUSE OF THEIR LOW POLLUTION POTENTIAL

time to read

2 mins

October 12, 2025

Listen

Translate

Share

-
+

Change font size