Intentar ORO - Gratis
The 69% Exception
Outlook
|September 21, 2024
Quota within quota: lessons to be learned from Tamil Nadu
THE Supreme Court of India, in its historic judgement on August 1, 2024, permitting sub-classification Ton within the Scheduled Caste category, referred to an article authored by Ravichandran Bathran that was published in the Economic and Political Weekly in November 2016. In Paragraph 141, the court states, "In Tamil Nadu, when an Arunthathiyar man and a Paraiyar woman-both the castes find a place in the Scheduled Castes (SC) list-eloped, the woman's family allegedly raped the women of the man's family in retaliation." The seven-judge bench relied on Bathran's article to justify the need for the sub-classification within the SC categories so as to argue that discrimination among and within the Dalit communities does exist in India.
Bathran, the man who has become a footnote' in the historic Supreme Court judgement, himself comes from the most downtrodden Chakliar/Arunthathiyar community in Tamil Nadu. Historically, the Chakliar/Arunthathiyar community was engaged in manual scavenging, a caste-based labour imposed on them. Bathran, a post-doctoral fellow, worked at the University of Southampton, South Africa. Despite being a scholar, Bathran runs a company for cleaning toilets. 'Going back' to manual scavenging was never a choice, says Bathran.
"I wanted to do research, but they shut the door on my face. I applied to around 10 universities to do research on manual scavenging. But none of the universities responded," he says.
He converted to Islam in 2022 and changed his name to Raees Mohammed. "As Ambedkar embraced Buddhism, I embraced Islam," says Mohammad. He runs the Kotagiri Septic Tank Cleaning Services Private Ltd, a company offering scavenging services in Nilagiri district.
Mohammed argues that the hierarchical layers of discrimination within the SC categories often go unnoticed because even some Dalit activists do not want to highlight them.
Pioneering Bahujan Politics
Esta historia es de la edición September 21, 2024 de Outlook.
Suscríbete a Magzter GOLD para acceder a miles de historias premium seleccionadas y a más de 9000 revistas y periódicos.
¿Ya eres suscriptor? Iniciar sesión
MÁS HISTORIAS DE Outlook
Outlook
The Big Blind Spot
Caste boundaries still shape social relations in Tamil Nadu-a state long rooted in self-respect politics
8 mins
December 11, 2025
Outlook
Jat Yamla Pagla Deewana
Dharmendra's tenderness revealed itself without any threats to his masculinity. He adapted himself throughout his 65-year-long career as both a product and creature of the times he lived through
5 mins
December 11, 2025
Outlook
Fairytale of a Fallow Land
Hope Bihar can once again be that impossibly noisy village in Phanishwar Nath Renu's Parti Parikatha-divided, yes, but still capable of insisting that rights are not favours and development is more than a slogan shouted from a stage
14 mins
December 11, 2025
Outlook
The Lesser Daughters of the Goddess
The Dravidian movement waged an ideological war against the devadasi system. As former devadasis lead a new wave of resistance, the practice is quietly sustained by caste, poverty, superstition and inherited ritual
2 mins
December 11, 2025
Outlook
The Meaning of Mariadhai
After a hundred years, what has happened to the idea of self-respect in contemporary Tamil society?
5 mins
December 11, 2025
Outlook
When the State is the Killer
The war on drugs continues to be a war on the poor
5 mins
December 11, 2025
Outlook
We Are Intellectuals
A senior law officer argued in the Supreme Court that \"intellectuals\" could be more dangerous than \"ground-level terrorists\"
5 mins
December 11, 2025
Outlook
An Equal Stage
The Dravidian Movement used novels, plays, films and even politics to spread its ideology
12 mins
December 11, 2025
Outlook
The Dignity in Self-Respect
How Periyar and the Self-Respect Movement took shape in Tamil Nadu and why the state has done better than the rest of the country on many social, civil and public parameters
5 mins
December 11, 2025
Outlook
When Sukumaar Met Elakkiya
Self-respect marriage remains a force of socio-political change even a century later
7 mins
December 11, 2025
Listen
Translate
Change font size
